WASHINGTON — Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan defended his legacy Wednesday, telling a special panel that’s looking into the origins of the financial crisis that insufficient bank capital and poor business decisions brought the nation to the brink of ruin, and it wasn’t his fault.

Greenspan’s appearance before the congressionally created Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission was much anticipated and didn’t disappoint. It included revelations that the Fed’s own internal reviews had found insufficient policing of Citigroup, which taxpayers later rescued. A regulator whom Greenspan had silenced also grilled him mercilessly.

“The Fed utterly failed to prevent the financial crisis,” Brooksley Born told Greenspan, after reeling off a litany of what she called failures by the central bank that helped bring about what Greenspan himself now labels the worst financial crisis ever.

Born was the chairman of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission in the late 1990s, and her unheeded warnings to Greenspan and other top Clinton administration officials came back to haunt the nation.

On Wednesday, she tried in vain to get Greenspan to acknowledge that deregulating the markets in 2000 allowed for an explosion of complex insurance-like products called credit-default swaps, which helped spark the collapse and rescue of insurer American International Group.

Greenspan said those products weren’t an issue at the time of deregulation, but Born reminded him that they became one of the principal causes of the financial meltdown in September 2008.

Advertisement

“Are you aware that the collapse of AIG was caused by its commitments under credit-default swaps that it had issued? The taxpayer has had to bail out AIG because of its exposure to credit-default swaps to the tune of more than $180 billion,” she told Greenspan.

At the end of the bitter exchange, Greenspan told Born, “I really fundamentally disagree with your point of view.”

He said the financial crisis occurred because regulators were unaware at the time that capital requirements – how much banks have to sock away to offset potential losses – were insufficient. Even this begrudging mea culpa from Greenspan, however, had a caveat.

Regulators “were undercapitalizing the banking system for 40 or 50 years,” he said, suggesting that the problem predated his 18-year tenure.

The other major cause, he said, was a breakdown at the originating point of mortgage finance, where lenders failed to know their clients, the borrowers, sufficiently. This can’t be regulated, he suggested, but it’s a fundamental part of doing business.

The explanation, however, misses the fact that regulators allowed popular no-documentation loans, in which a borrower who was willing to pay a quarter-point more on a lending rate could avoid having to document any income.

Advertisement

Commission Chairman Phil Angelides, a former California state treasurer, read Greenspan a long list of warnings from within the Fed about brewing problems in housing finance that were ignored.

“You could’ve, you should’ve and you didn’t,” he said.

Greenspan said the Fed couldn’t be blamed for insufficient bank regulation because it didn’t have supervisory powers over investment banks, which pooled millions of poorly underwritten loans for sale to investors. That responsibility fell to the Securities and Exchange Commission, which monitored the banks for investor protection – but not for their safety and soundness becaues it wasn’t a bank regulator.

Today the commission will hear from Chuck Prince, the former Citigroup CEO who famously explained Wall Street’s inability to step back from the abyss by saying that as long as the music was playing, he had to dance. Robert Rubin, a Citi CEO before he became the economic face of the Clinton administration as treasury secretary, also will go before the commission.


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.