The “Merry Christmas wars” have become as constant a feature in our holiday preparations in recent years as colored lights and sleigh bells.

That’s the name given to the awkwardness some people feel about publicly observing a major religious holiday, and the hurt felt by others who see their traditions being taken away from them.

Court rulings that interpret the First Amendment’s ban on establishing a state religion as a ban on government-funded holiday observances in schools and public property add to the sense of unease.

This has led to what some in our community looks like an inconsistency: Monument Square is the site of a lighted tree, called, in an overabundance of sensitivity, just a tree (never mind what kind) by the people who put it up.

Then, on the first day of Hanukkah, Portland celebrated with the lighting of a menorah in City Hall Plaza.

Why does one religion get to have an overtly religious symbol of its holiday, but another has to be sneaky about putting up a marginally religious symbol of its?

Advertisement

The difference is that the tree was set up by a downtown business group that wants to maximize business. They are free to call it whatever they want and so are the rest of us. (We call it a Christmas tree.)

City Hall Plaza hosts the menorah and will soon host a Christmas tree as well. City officials say even more overtly religious demonstrations — like a nativity scene — could also be placed there without a legal problem.

As long as the government does not discriminate between religions, we can all celebrate, and there is nothing in this war to fight over.

 


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.