If this were an episode of “Law & Order,” it would all be over by now.
Police investigators, armed with an instantaneous DNA analysis, would have run Gary Irving’s genetic profile through any and all rape kits collected throughout Irving’s 34-year charade as a quiet, peaceful resident of quiet, peaceful Gorham. And within mere seconds, they’d have tied the thrice-convicted Massachusetts rapist to one, two … who knows how many unsolved rapes all over Maine.
“It’s the modern-day fingerprint,” noted Maine State Police Trooper Jeremy Forbes on Tuesday as he awaited Irving’s DNA report from a crime lab in Massachusetts. “It puts you at the crime.”
Assuming, of course, Maine has crimes at which Irving can be put.
This much we know: As an 18-year-old living on Massachusetts’ South Shore, Irving sexually assaulted three women — including one at knifepoint in his car and another whom he knocked from her bicycle before brutally and repeatedly raping her in a secluded area.
Then, on the weekend before he was to receive a possible lifetime prison sentence, he skipped bail and headed north to Maine — not to be seen or heard from until police showed up at his doorstep last week.
So what happened during all those years on the lam? Did Irving, now 52, simply flip a switch on his animalistic ways and reinvent himself as a law-abiding Everyman?
Or are there other women, right here in Maine, who know otherwise?
As Forbes and other investigators begin the months-long task of retracing Irving’s steps over so many years, only one thing is certain: They’ll be searching for tiny needles in a horrifyingly huge haystack.
“I don’t envy them that task, for certain,” said Cara Courchesne, communications and outreach coordinator for the Maine Coalition Against Sexual Assault.
Let’s go to the numbers.
We begin with the Maine Department of Public Safety’s annual Uniform Crime Reports, where a quick tabulation shows 3,286 forcible rapes reported in Maine from 2002 to 2011. Only 1,608 cases — fewer than half — have been cleared by police.
In other words, 1,678 victims of forcible rape in Maine have yet to see justice. Some are still waiting for their rapist to be caught, others undoubtedly are despairing that their case is too old, too cold and too dusty to warrant another look.
But even those hard numbers, as Courchesne notes in a whopper of an understatement, “are not quite as accurate as what we see.”
According to the “Maine Crime Victimization Report,” a survey done in 2011 by the University of Southern Maine’s Muskie School of Public Service, one in five Maine adults — the vast majority of them women — have been victims of rape or attempted rape.
In fact, the study showed that every 12 months, an estimated 13,000 Mainers suffer rape or unwanted sexual activity.
“They’re everywhere,” said Amy Thomas, executive director of Sexual Assault Response Services of Southern Maine.
Some, Thomas noted, seek help immediately. Others wait years to step forward — if they make themselves known at all.
“It just all depends on where they are in their healing process — and the support systems that they may or may not have,” Thomas said. “But we do find that many victims and survivors can be triggered when something like (Irving’s arrest) comes up. Our crisis and support line gets quite busy.”
Irving, of course, was but one of thousands of rapists living in the shadows before police, alerted by a disgruntled relative in Massachusetts, zeroed in on his home in Gorham last week.
Since fleeing here from Massachusetts in 1979, Irving had married, raised a family and lived what by all accounts so far was a law-abiding life under the assumed first name of “Gregg.”
“We’re not hoping that he did anything up here,” said Trooper Forbes, who will begin his search by running Irving’s DNA profile against those already in Maine’s sexual assault database. “But if we didn’t check into it, we wouldn’t be doing justice to anyone out there who’s one of these open cases.”
Beyond the DNA, Forbes said, investigators will do their best to track Irving’s movements over the years and cross-check them with open cases still on file in scores of local law enforcement agencies. With luck, those departments may have retained evidence that has yet to be tested for DNA — whether it matches Irving’s or not, it will at least be added to the database.
Meanwhile, the keepers of Maine’s sexual assault hotlines wait — if not for the rest of Irving’s story, then for the countless other victims out there who have been paralyzed by scars, both physical and emotional, that can last a lifetime.
“There’s a reprocessing that for a lot of people will accompany this event,” said Courchesne. “It might bring up a lot of emotions related to how they were feeling at the time (they were assaulted) — anger, sadness, all of those things.”
Maybe you — or someone you know — have been feeling those things since the news cameras showed police walking a handcuffed Irving from the comfort of his suburban home to a long overdue court appearance.
Maybe your family, just like Irving’s, has long-held secrets that need to be told.
Maybe you’ve simply stayed too quiet for too long while someone who should be behind bars acts like nothing ever happened.
Whatever the reason, a sympathetic ear awaits you at (800) 871-7741, the Maine Coalition Against Sexual Assault’s statewide hotline. Or, if that’s busy, call Sexual Assault Response Services of Southern Maine’s direct line at (800) 313-9900.
Can they dissolve your troubles in less than an hour as those miracle workers on TV do?
Not a chance.
But they have all the time in the world to listen.
Bill Nemitz can be contacted at 791-6323 or at: