Monday, March 10, 2014
Matt Danner stands in a corn field on his farm near Templeton, Iowa, earlier this month. Danner, part of a five-generation farm family, says he still recalls watching grown men cry at sales of failed farms. At 33, he says this is the best time to farm he’s seen in 15 years. “It takes 10 good years to fix the five bad ones of the ’80s,” he said. “It’s going to go the other way. It always does. There’s plenty of history to prove it’s not going to last long.”
The Associated Press
Bidding starts at $5,000 an acre.
A year ago, that would have been about the going price for good land in this southern Minnesota county. On this day in March, the bids climb much higher, past the county record set just a month earlier. After a few tense minutes, Schmiesing wins out with an offer of $8,375 an acre.
He looks a bit stunned -- he just spent $670,000.
Is the land worth it? "I have no idea," he says. "I'll tell you in five years."
Across Minnesota and the Midwest, concerns are rising that farm values are climbing too high. Farmers, bankers and investors have put huge sums of money on the line, in the hope that boom times for agriculture will last.
Land prices have reached levels not seen in a century, even adjusted for inflation, mainly because historically high prices for commodities such as corn and soybeans have enabled farmers to generate strong profits. Good times are spurring farmers to expand their holdings and newcomers to buy in.
But economists and analysts wonder whether farmland will continue to provide the kind of payoff that justifies the high-dollar purchases. Or whether farm prices are vulnerable to the kind of momentum shifts that hit dot-com stocks and then housing.
"If (prices) keep going up at the rates at which they have been going up, they will not be justifiable," said Brent Gloy, director of Purdue University's Center for Commercial Agriculture.
Farming's last golden era also started with high commodity prices and a big run-up in land values -- only to collapse into what became the 1980s farm crisis. Legions of farmers went bankrupt and land values plummeted, devastating rural economies.
Many observers say farmers are at less risk this time because they aren't carrying as much debt as they were in the '80s. But signs of overinflated land prices have people on guard that the market may be peaking.
"As a conservative banker, I'm concerned every day," said Michael Bahl, principal agriculture industry specialist at Wells Fargo Bank in Owatonna, Minn. He thinks Minnesota farmland that has reached $8,000 to $10,000 an acre is "too high."
Purdue's Gloy watches the "value-to-cash rent multiple" of farmland, which indicates how much buyers are paying for each dollar of rent they could collect for the land. A high number suggests that buyers may be overpaying.
The ratio hit a high in Minnesota in 2007 and remains at levels not seen in 45 years, according to a Star Tribune newspaper analysis of U.S. Department of Agriculture data. It's at similar highs in Iowa, Illinois and Indiana and hasn't fallen back in those states, according to Gloy's analysis.
"We're in uncharted territory," he said.
Farming is the ultimate hard-luck profession, forever at the mercy of weather and faceless commodity markets. In recent years, though, the rewards for many crop farmers have been bountiful.
Sitting in his home office in southwest Minnesota overlooking two large, shiny steel corn bins, Gene Stoel sums up the past couple of years: "It's been very easy to make money," said Stoel, 57, a veteran corn and soybean farmer near Lake Wilson, Minn. "This has been a very good age for farming."
Minnesota crop farmers had two of their most profitable years on record in 2010 and 2011, posting an annual median net income of over $145,000 after farm expenses, according to data from the University of Minnesota and the Minnesota State Colleges and Universities. Surging income has helped put farmers in a financial position to expand.
Last fall, Stoel bought 160 acres, increasing the size of his farm by about a quarter. "You've got to keep growing or you'll be left behind," Stoel said.
He paid $6,300 an acre. Three years ago, he bought an 80-acre parcel. It's a little less fertile than his recent purchase, but it cost only $3,200 per acre.
Tom Haag, a 60-year-old corn and soybean farmer near Eden Valley, Minn., expanded last year, too. He bought 200 acres that almost doubled the size of his farm as part of an effort to bring his son into the family business.
Haag paid just under $4,000 an acre for land that probably would have cost 30 percent less three or four years ago.
"I was not feeling good for three or four days," Haag said. "I've never spent that much money in my life. I want a couple of good years because I don't want to go backwards."
Last year the average price for an acre of cropland jumped 9 percent nationally, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
One factor that adds to the pressure on prices is that there just isn't much land for sale. Only 1 percent of Minnesota's farmland generally comes up for sale in a given year. And despite hot demand, the number of farm real estate sales has actually been falling, hitting its lowest point in decades, said University of Minnesota economist Steven Taff, who tracks farm real estate sales across the state. For a farmer, land coming up for sale next door can be a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
Farmers can thank much of their current good fortune to the combination of historically high commodity prices and historically low interest rates.
High prices for corn and other grains, of course, boost farm income. Low rates make borrowing cheaper and intrinsically raise the value of a farm.
Farmers entered a new price era about five years ago. Until about 2007, the long-term average price for corn -- going back at least 30 years -- was around $2.50 per bushel. Then prices for corn and other commodities began climbing in what experts see as a structural change driven by global food and fuel demand.
The thirst for corn-based ethanol has risen sharply. Plus the swell of people entering the middle class in countries such as China and India has buoyed demand for meat, and thus for soybeans and corn for animal feed.
Growing world demand for food has come at the same time that global grain supplies have been tight. With subpar weather, U.S. corn yields have been below long-term trends in recent years.
The result: corn above $5 and soybeans around $13 -- both above historical benchmarks.
Said Stoel: "I never thought it would get this good."
There are so many risks that Bahl, the Wells Fargo banker, joked he can't list them all. "Any one thing could cause that disaster," he said.
Interest rates will inevitably rise at some point, although the Federal Reserve has made clear that it intends to hold rate targets low until at least 2014. Ethanol demand has slowed, and farm economists say that without federal policy changes, the days of go-go growth for the corn-based fuel are gone.
"Corn is land, and land is corn," said Michael Swanson, an agricultural economist with Wells Fargo in Minneapolis. "If we have $6 corn prices going forward, these land prices are fine. We really need to have a couple of monster crops to see how low these prices might go."
Producers themselves, and the age-old specter of such "monster crops," pose their own threat. Farmers worldwide, not surprisingly, react to higher prices by planting more, which in turn can lead to bumper crops that inevitably lead to price declines. U.S. corn farmers were expected to plant more acres in corn this year than any time since 1937.
"In the past, farmers have tended to produce themselves out of prosperity," said Jason Henderson, an economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City.
Then there are the rising costs for farm essentials such as fertilizer and seed. Indeed, despite Minnesota crop farmers' banner year in 2011, profits were still down almost 10 percent from 2010 due to higher costs.
Bankers are busy charting the shrinking profit margins. A sudden spike in oil prices, for instance, could alter the farm equation.The risks aren't lost on farmers. Schmiesing, who just bought the 80 acres in Blue Earth County to grow more corn, said he's perfectly aware of them. He just doesn't think corn prices will fall "for a while."
He and his brother, who run a hog operation, had to mortgage some of the 1,500 acres they farm with their father to pay for the new land. He said he probably wouldn't have bought if it hadn't been right next door.
"It's just like going to Morton, you know," said Schmiesing, referring to the Jackpot Junction Casino in Morton, Minn. "That's what farming is, it's a gamble every day.
"It's good right now. I don't know how long it will last."