August 15, 2013

Indie Film: Faith alone can't ensure smooth sailing

The documentary screens at Nickelodeon in Portland at 7 p.m. Thursday.


A description of the new documentary "Raw Faith" -- which premiered at the Maine International Film Festival in July and screens at the Nickelodeon in Portland at 7 p.m. Thursday -- sounds like the sort of nice, well-meaning inspirational story that secretly makes peoples' eyes glaze over: The true-life tale of a Maine family's dream of building a ship in order to take people with special needs on sea cruises.

click image to enlarge

Looking like something that castaways built, the Raw Faith was assembled with castoff lumber and tar ... not to mention an eccentric man’s dreams.

Courtesy of Gregory Roscoe

This is raw footage from the actual 2010 U.S. Coast Guard rescue of Raw Faith 100 miles southeast of Nantucket, Mass., after the boat became disabled. Video by Air Station Cape Cod.


"RAW FAITH: A FAMILY SAGA" will screen at 7 p.m. Thursday at Nickelodeon Cinema, 1 Temple St., Portland; and 2, 5 and 8 p.m. Aug. 25 at The Frontier, 14 Maine St., Mill 3, Fort Andross, Brunswick

MORE: Visit for additional screenings.




Thursday: "Sally of the Sawdust." The venerable Ogunquit theater's summer silent movie series continues with this 1925 D.W. Griffith tale of a young woman who grows up in the circus and has to deal with some dark secrets of her parentage. Co-starring W.C. Fields and with live musical accompaniment from musician Jeff Rapsis.



Monday: "Hey Bartender." Bring your IDs to this one, Portland hooch aficionados, as Space brings in Portland mixologist extraordinaire Nan'l Meiklejohn to whip up some of the high-end cocktails featured in this documentary about two young men attempting to make their bartending dreams come true amidst the rebirth of cocktail culture in New York City.

Instead, Gregory Roscoe's compelling film recalls nothing so much as a Maine version of a Werner Herzog movie, where a man becomes obsessed with an eccentric dream that brings him too close to the inherent dangers of nature, and risks losing literally everything to his quest.

Specifically, the decade-long journey of Maine electrical engineer-turned self-taught shipbuilder George McKay recalls Herzog's film "Fitzcarraldo," in which a man with a seemingly impossible dream attempts to haul an enormous steamship over a rainforest mountain. In "Raw Faith," McKay sells his home and enlists his family in a quixotic plan to build a massive, fully functional replica of a three-masted galleon in order to take physically challenged people and their families on ocean voyages.

Working for years on a roadside in Addison alongside his three sons, his wife and his daughter (who's afflicted with Marfan's Syndrome), McKay, touting the knowledge gathered from "a couple dozen books," did indeed create the Raw Faith -- a 118-foot-long, 300-ton behemoth.

Which is impressive, even if the Raw Faith would never win any beauty contests. Or inspire any confidence whatsoever in anyone who saw it.

Lovingly (and awkwardly) hammered together from castoff lumber and slathered with tar and George's steadfast dreams, the ship, looking like something castaways cobbled together to escape a desert isle, was finally launched in 2003. Like almost everything involved in the ship's career, the launching provokes in the viewer a mix of admiration, elation and intense anxiety that the all-around ramshackle enterprise will come crashing down on the heads of the McKay family.

That ambivalence permeates the film, with harbormasters, Coast Guard officials and gradually even the members of George McKay's family expressing their respect for what the man has accomplished alongside a growing unease with his single-minded and often unfathomable fixation on making the Raw Faith what he dreamed it would be.

Over 10 years, we see the idealistic McKay change, hardening in his approach to his family, bristling at the quite reasonable concerns and regulations of maritime officials, and introducing talk of God's will and Satan's obstacles to his mission's narrative.

Eventually driving away even the one son who sailed with him for years as his only crew, he rails against what he considers his family's abandonment with a sad, suppressed rage that's both affecting -- and alienating. To Fitzcarraldo, add elements of King Lear, Noah and Ahab.

This level of emotional complexity is very impressive, as McKay's decade-long odyssey reaches what seems its inevitable conclusion: What began as an unapologetic celebration of one man's eccentric dream becomes instead the gripping tale of what happens when monomaniacal passion clashes with the needs of others -- and the unforgiving sea.

Dennis Perkins is a Portland freelance writer.


Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)


More PPH Blogs

Get the GO RSS!