December 8, 2013

Loss of shrimp season hits the pocketbook hardest

The Gulf of Maine has been closed to shrimping for 2014 after last year’s low harvest.

By Gillian Graham
Staff Writer

NOBLEBORO — Behind Tim Simmons’ house, down a hill past piles of coiled rope and brightly painted bundles of lobster buoys, sit 100 shrimp traps.

Today's poll: Shrimp season

Do you agree with the Atlantic States Maine Fisheries Commission's decision to cancel the Maine shrimp season?



View Results

click image to enlarge

Gulls follow a shrimp fishing boat as crewmen haul in their catch in the Gulf of Maine in 2012. The Gulf of Maine shrimp population has fallen to the lowest level on record, setting the stage for a shutdown of the fishery this coming winter.

click image to enlarge

Additional Photos Below

2004 Telegram file photo

Maine shrimp on ice at the Portland Fish Exchange after the opening day of the shrimp fishing season in 2004. 

What’s so special about Maine shrimp?

Americans eat more shrimp than any other type of seafood – more than 4 pounds per person in 2011, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

Maine shrimp, also known as northern shrimp, are wild-caught in the North Atlantic by trawlers or traps by fishermen in Maine, New Hampshire and Massachusetts. The same species, Pandalus borealis, can also be found in the Arctic and the North Pacific; it’s in the southern end of its range in New England. The shrimp available at the grocery store are, for the most part, farmed in other countries. Most shrimp imported to this country, according to NOAA, comes from Southeast Asian countries such as Thailand, Indonesia and China, followed by Ecuador and Mexico.

More than 90 percent of the shrimp eaten in this country is farmed overseas, in countries where environmental standards are more lax. Shrimp farms use different methods – some are trying to grow shrimp more sustainably now – but for the most part these farms have issues with pollution, habitat destruction and the spread of disease.

Maine shrimp is mostly sold fresh at local retailers, while imported shrimp is mostly frozen before it’s shipped, then defrosted or sold frozen when it reaches local markets. Maine shrimp is also sold frozen, canned or smoked.

Maine shrimp is pinkish to reddish in color, and often sold with the large heads still on. But they are easier to process – the thin shells slip right off – and they don’t need to be deveined.

Maine shrimp are tiny compared to the farmed shrimp in the freezer case. They’re usually only a couple of inches long, although they can reach four inches, and have an average count of 50 per pound. Because they are so small, and have such a delicate, sweet flavor, many people prefer to just eat them raw. They also make a delicious ceviche preparation.

If they’re cooked, they should only be exposed to heat for a minute or two, never longer than two minutes, or their tender texture will turn tough. 

One Portland restaurant group plans for a lack of Maine shrimp

At Miyake, “Maine Shrimp Three Ways” has been a customer favorite since 2007. The dish is three different preparations of Maine shrimp on one plate – sashimi; ceviche-style with lime, lemon, truffle oil and sansho pepper; and shrimp with tamari and mirin. Pai Men Miyake serves a wok-fried Maine shrimp, prepared with heads on in a spicy garlic sauce.

Will Garfield, co-owner of the Miyake restaurants, said that without Maine shrimp as an option, the chefs will likely focus more on preparations like ankimo, a Japanese dish made with monkfish liver. “In colder months, (monkfish liver) is not as bitter as it can be in summer,” he said.

They’ll probably also serve more whelk harvested from Casco Bay. They already buy 100 pounds of it at the beginning of the year, and Garfield said that as far as he knows, they are the only place in town that serves it.

Garfield said Miyake occasionally uses farmed shrimp, but “I prefer not to use them. I think if you’re using shrimp, it’s got to be fresh, and I like to know where it comes from because from what I’ve read, the condition(s) in a lot of those farms are not ideal.”

The loss of Maine shrimp is “a loss for everybody,” he said, “but at the same time we need to protect the fishery, so it’s completely understandable. I’d rather lose them this year and have them come back stronger for the future.”

– Meredith Goad

The traps – some purple, some black, all relatively new – will remain unused this winter for the first time in the 14 years Simmons has been shrimping in the Gulf of Maine.

“It’s hard to have them sitting there not making money,” Simmons said Thursday, three days after regulators announced there will be no 2014 season.

The Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission last week voted to close the Gulf of Maine to shrimping after a harvest last winter that was the smallest since the last fishery shutdown in 1978.

Fishermen say they are disappointed but not surprised.

Last summer, a survey indicated the northern shrimp stock was at its lowest level since 1984, when annual trawl surveys began. A November report from the commission’s Northern Shrimp Technical Committee concluded the stock has collapsed, in part because of warming ocean temperatures.

The report recommended a moratorium on shrimping in 2014 to maximize the spawning potential. In an average year, the Gulf of Maine accounts for about 3 percent of the country’s total shrimp catch. This year, Maine’s 181 shrimping boats landed a total catch of more than 677,000 pounds of northern shrimp.

The loss of income – upwards of $2,000 a day for some shrimpers when prices and the fishing are good – will be painful for Simmons and other Maine fishermen who rely on it to supplement the money they make lobstering and fishing. Shrimp processors fear their industry will be harmed as people looking for northern shrimp turn to other markets.

“What closing the season down does is send a message to all the markets that this is a very risky resource to be playing in,” said Spencer Fuller, the shrimp product line manger for Cozy Harbor Seafood Inc. in Portland, the largest shrimp processor in the state.

Historically, northern shrimp have provided a small but valuable fishery to Maine, New Hampshire and Massachusetts. The fishery for northern shrimp was worth an estimated $1.2 million in its limited 2013 season. In 2011, it was worth more than $10 million, according to regulators.

The commercial fishery began in the late 1950s and landings peaked in 1969 with 28.3 million pounds. Over the next decade, landings decreased dramatically to a low of less than 85,000 pounds in 1977, according to the fisheries commission.

The fishery was closed in 1978 because of a stock collapse. Since then, annual catches have been cyclical, with years of both record catches and seasons cut short after less than three weeks.


For fishermen who cobble together a livelihood by fishing lobster, shrimp, scallops and groundfish, those fluctuations in the fishery are part of life. Some 84 percent of people who fish for shrimp in Maine are also lobstermen; the rest mostly fish for groundfish before converting their boats for the short shrimp season. It’s almost unheard of for someone to fish solely for shrimp, according to fishermen.

Despite recent seasons that were cut short, Simmons said he was still able to make good money shrimping in the winter months, when lobstering slows down.

“It can be good money,” said Simmons, who is president of the Maine Shrimp Trappers Association board of directors. “It’s not like you just throw a trap in a boat and go fish. It’s time-consuming. It’s a lot of back-breaking work.”

Simmons, 52, is used to that tough work. A third-generation lobsterman, his calloused hands are a testament to the years he’s spent throwing and hauling traps off his boat, Trav-Lin. He first started going out on the water with his dad at age 5.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Additional Photos

click image to enlarge

Shrimp fisherman Tim Simmons of Nobleboro stands next to the roughly 100 shrimp traps that won’t be used for the 2014 season.

Gabe Souza/Staff Photographer

click image to enlarge

Roger Collard unloads totes of shrimp from the hold of the Theresa Irene III after the boat tied up to the pier at Camp Ellis in Saco in 2006.

Telegram file photo/Gregory Rec


Further Discussion

Here at we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)

Today's poll: Shrimp season

Do you agree with the Atlantic States Maine Fisheries Commission's decision to cancel the Maine shrimp season?



View Results