January 13

Maine Supreme Court to hear appeal in New Gloucester double murder

Lawyers for Joel Hayden, 32, contend he should have been convicted of manslaughter instead of murder because of the ‘high dose of oxycodone and cocaine’ in his system.

By Scott Dolan sdolan@pressherald.com
Staff Writer

The Maine Supreme Judicial Court is scheduled to hear an appeal Wednesday from a man convicted of murder nearly a year ago for shooting to death his childhood friend and the mother of his four children.

click image to enlarge

Joel Hayden

Renee Sandora, New Glucester shooting victim, with her son Ja'kai.

Courtesy photo

Joel Hayden, 32, was convicted after a jury trial in which his son, who was 7 years old at the time of the killings in 2011, testified against him.

Without looking once at his father in the courtroom, the boy was the most powerful witness against his father, describing seeing Hayden shoot his mother, Renee Sandora, and his friend Trevor Mills at Sandora’s home in New Gloucester.

Hayden is arguing in the appeal filed by his attorneys, Clifford Strike and Sarah Churchill, that the evidence presented at trial was only enough to convict him of manslaughter, not murder, and that the trial judge erred in sentencing him to two life terms.

He was “under the influence of a high dose of oxycodone and cocaine on the day of the shooting,” leading to doubts whether he could have the necessary state of mind for a murder conviction, Strike said in a written brief filed in support of the appeal. To prove murder, prosecutors had to show Hayden acted intentionally or knowingly.

The Supreme Judicial Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments on his appeal Wednesday afternoon.

Hayden’s eldest son, Ja’kai, who testified against him, is now being raised by Sandora’s mother and stepfather, Patricia and Mark Gerber, along with Sandora and Hayden’s three other children. They live one-fifth of a mile up the road from where the shootings took place.

Patricia Gerber said she and other family members will attend the oral arguments, but she has not told any of the children about it.

“It feels like it’s never, ever going to be over. It’s always something,” she said.

Gerber said that a year after the trial and 2½ years after the shooting, Ja’kai’s nightmares have subsided and he doesn’t seem to dwell often on the horrors he witnessed.

“He’s happy. He doesn’t talk about it,” she said. But “a few weeks ago, he was talking about people playing video games and all the shooting. I told him other kids didn’t see the things he did. And he said, ‘I still see it in my head sometimes.’”

While Hayden’s attorneys argue in the appeal that the evidence shown at trial was enough to support a manslaughter conviction, Hayden contends in an online profile for a prisoner pen pal program that he was framed for both murders.

“I got setup for a crime I didn’t commit. The truth will set me free; I will leave everything in the Gods hands until my future appeal processes,” Hayden says in his profile on www.writeaprisoner.com.

Adam Lovell, the president and owner of the website, said his company tracks which profiles are written by the inmates themselves, but he does not disclose that information.

“A lot of them are written by friends and family. You can sometimes tell, and you sometimes can’t,” Lovell said of the inmate profiles.

Prosecutors maintain that the evidence shown during Hayden’s weeklong trial last January was sufficient to convict him of murder and the two life sentences were justified.

“Hayden was insanely jealous of Renee Sandora despite the fact that she gave him no reason to be so,” Assistant Attorney General Donald Macomber said in a written brief filed with the Supreme Judicial Court. “Hayden told a drug customer the day before the murders that he was ‘going to kill that bitch and get his boy too.’ In the days before the murders, Hayden, a convicted felon, was target practicing with his Colt .45 handgun.”

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)