November 29, 2012

Maine company, pipeline make 'Dirty Dozen' polluters list

Casella Waste Management has a long history in Maine, while a tar sands pipeline has yet to establish one.

By North Cairn
Staff Writer

An environmental group has targeted what it considers Maine's two most serious environmental threats in its annual "Dirty Dozen" list of polluters in New England.

click image to enlarge

Casella has been negotiating with the city of Biddeford for the $6.65 million sale of the Maine Energy Recovery Co. trash-to-energy incinerator there.

Press Herald file photo

Related Documents

Read the Toxic Action Center's full report

Toxic Action Center's 2012 Dirty Dozen

Hartford - Connecticut Resources Recovery Authority
Marlborough - Connecticut Environmental Council
Stratford - Raymark Superfund Site

Old Town - Casella Waste
Scarborough - Casella Waste
South Portland - Tar Sands Pipeline

New Bedford - New Bedford Harbor and Parker Street Waste Site
Pittsfield - General Electric
Plymouth - Energy Nuclear
Somerset - Brayton Point Coal Plant
South Hadley - Advanced Disposal

New Hampshire
Bow - Public Service of New Hampshire Coal Plants
Portsmouth - Public Service of New Hampshire Coal Plants

Rhode Island
Johnston - Central Landfill

Moretown - Advanced Disposal
Vernon - Energy Nuclear

One of the two has a long history in Maine while the other that has yet to establish one.

The Toxics Action Center, a New England grassroots environmental organization established in 1987, named the waste handling company Casella Waste Management Inc. among its 12 most flagrant polluters because of continuing issues surrounding garbage dumps and waste burning dating to the mid-1980s.

The other offender is still looming on the horizon – the proposed tar sands pipeline that some opponents say could prove to be a huge environmental threat.

Casella, which operates numerous landfills, dumps and incinerators around the state, has long been at the center of debates over the hazards posed by out-of-state toxic wastes and chemicals in landfills.

"The worst remain the worst," said Tracie Konopinski, community organizer with the Portland office of the Toxics Action Center, a Boston-based nonprofit devoted to preventing and cleaning up pollution in New England neighborhoods and making communities more sustainable. Casella has appeared on earlier Dirty Dozen lists, she said.

"The threat long term (from Casella landfills and incinerators) is enormous," said Ed Spencer of Orono Community Forums, who lives less than two miles from Casella's landfill in Old Town and has been part of a citizen watchdog effort monitoring Casella's operations in northern Maine. "They're great at making promises, but they've failed to deliver."

Casella officials could not be reached for comment Tuesday. The company has been negotiating with the city of Biddeford for the $6.65 million sale of the Maine Energy Recovery Co. trash-to-energy incinerator there.

Now operating in 14 states, Casella contracts for refuse pickup and transport, dumpster rental and recycling for residential, commercial, municipal and industrial customers.

Toxics Action Center also cited on its list the tar sands pipeline proposed to transport oil from Ontario, Canada, through the lakes region in southwestern Maine and on to Portland, where it could be shipped out by supertankers. The proposed pipeline represents a new threat to the state and region, Konopinski said.

"ExxonMobil's tar sands pipeline is very worthy of this award," said Emily Figdor of the environmental advocacy group Environment Maine. "Tar sands oil, the dirtiest oil in the world, could soon be coursing through an outdated oil pipeline that crosses the Sebago Lake watershed and ends in Casco Bay."

Konopinski said the oil proposed for the pipeline is "more corrosive than conventional oil" and would present almost insurmountable problems in cleanup, should an accident or leak ever occur.

The Toxics Action Center suggests several measures for dealing with persistent polluters, including replacing toxic chemicals with safer alternatives, requiring polluters to pay for hazardous waste cleanup, ensuring that discarded resources are recycled, and pursuing renewable energy.

This year's Dirty Dozen list is the first the organization has issued since 2007. It was culled from about 30 industries and businesses nominated by New England environmental groups, community leaders, public health officials, activists and residents.

Staff Writer North Cairn can be contacted at 791-6325 or at:

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)