December 11, 2012

Critics say Munjoy Hill design is too 'boxy'

The proposed performance hall design does have supporters, but critics also cite potential parking issues.

By Dennis Hoey dhoey@pressherald.com
Staff Writer

PORTLAND – Plans for a 400-seat performance hall on Munjoy Hill got mixed reviews at a neighborhood meeting that drew about 75 people Monday night.

click image to enlarge

David Lloyd, the design architect for a proposed 400-seat performance venue on Munjoy Hill, talks with resident Bobbi Keppel after a meeting Monday while Frank Bishop – a St. Lawrence Arts Center board member – looks on.

Derek Davis / Staff Photographer

click image to enlarge

The latest design for the proposed Munjoy Hill performance hall, as presented to neighbors on December 10 by the Friends of the St. Lawrence Church.

Archetype Architects

Additional Photos Below

While supporters said the venue would be a catalyst for positive changes in the neighborhood, others questioned its contemporary design and whether there is enough space for parking in the area to accommodate so many people.

The Friends of the St. Lawrence Church have proposed the modern-looking, 410-seat performance hall on the site where the church's sanctuary once stood, at 76 Congress St.

Monday's meeting was held to get residents familiar with the proposal and gather input before the friends group goes before city boards for approval.

Organizers told residents that the plan could change, especially the building design.

"This is our first step, to present the plan to the neighborhood," said David Lloyd, the project's architect.

"There is nothing cast in stone here."

Last week, the Friends of the St. Lawrence Church presented their plan to the city's Historic Preservation Board for preliminary review.

They still need final approval from the preservation board, as well as the Planning Board, and an amendment of a contract zone that the City Council approved in 2010.

In 2010, the group got preliminary city approval for a hall that would have had the same amount of seating and replicated the 19th-century Gothic-style exterior of the St. Lawrence church and bell tower -- which were demolished in 2008 after being deemed a safety hazard by the city.

Potential donors balked at the estimated $12 million to $17 million cost of that plan, so the Friends of the St. Lawrence Church regrouped and proposed a new performance hall, which would cost about $7 million to build.

The new hall would be covered with a perforated metal skin that would be backlit at night. It would have a promenade room above the theater -- a space where people could gather for meetings or to look out over the city and Portland Harbor.

Vana Carmona, a Munjoy Hill resident, said she was "a little bit in shock" when she saw a rendering of the building in the Portland Press Herald.

"I'm not feeling the 'wow' factor with this building," Carmona said. "I feel like I've seen this building a few too many times" in her travels around the world.

Others described Lloyd's proposal as "boxy" and out of character with the surrounding buildings.

"I feel the design here does not really represent the city in any way," said Barbara Epstein, a tour guide who lives in North Deering. "I don't want visitors saying, 'What is that monstrosity?'"

"I don't think the design is quite there yet," said Jamie Parker. "It's a bit boxy."

Parker said he would support a contemporary design because it would celebrate the changes -- new businesses and home modernizations -- that are happening on Munjoy Hill.

Cliff Gallant described the design as a "big rectangular box." He called on the Friends group to provide an alternative that's more in character with the neighborhood.

Deirdre Nice, executive director of the Friends of the St. Lawrence Church, said the new venue would host concerts, plays and community meetings.

Some people questioned whether there is adequate space for parking to support such a large concert venue.

Nice said the 2010 plan that was approved by the city calls for satellite parking lots and a shuttle service. 

Staff Writer Dennis Hoey can be contacted at 791-6365 or at:

dhoey@pressherald.com

 

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors


Additional Photos

click image to enlarge

This earlier design, presented to the city's Historic Preservation Board on December 12, shows a 54-foot tall structure with metal siding proposed by the Friends of the St. Lawrence Church.

click image to enlarge

Munjoy Hill resident John Wuesthoff voices his concerns during the meeting Monday.

Derek Davis / Staff Photographer

 


Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)