April 28, 2013

Bill Nemitz: Old Orchard turmoil bad for business

Here's the typical short list of priorities for Old Orchard Beach, as least the way local businessman George Kerr sees it, as Maine's summertime mecca awakens from another long winter:

"Make sure we have our (parking) meters up, make sure you can generate revenue, make sure you have personnel for the summer, clean the beach, get the sidewalks clean and get the doors open so we can say, 'Welcome!' " said Kerr, owner of the local Surf 6 Oceanfront Grille & Bar and various of other tourist-related properties, in an interview last week.

Now here's a sign, literally, of what currently stands in the way of Old Orchard Beach's raison d'etre:

"The Town Clerk's office will be closed starting Friday, April 12, to certify Recall Petitions," read the printed notice by the entrance to the town hall last week. "If this is urgent, please go upstairs to the Town Manager's Office for assistance."

That or burrow into a sand dune and pray for this community to regain its sanity.

Friday afternoon, Town Clerk Kim McLaughlin notified three local town councilors -- Michael Coleman, Robin Dayton and Robert Quinn -- that petitions calling for their ouster contained enough valid signatures to force an election on whether they should be booted from office.

This on the heels of an identical finding earlier last week that has the town council's four other members -- Chairwoman Sharri MacDonald, Vice Chairwoman Laura Bolduc, Dana Furtado and Linda Mailhot -- also facing the democracy's ultimate indignity.

You heard that right, lucky citizens of anywhere-but-Old Orchard Beach. Sometime between now and the first day of summer on June 21, the entire elected leadership for one of Maine's highest-profile communities could very well be thrown out on its collective keister.

Goodbye, Maine's "Garden by the Sea." Hello, "Dysfunction Junction."

"We're all very embarrassed," said Kerr, who over the years has served both on the town council and as Old Orchard Beach's four-term state representative. "There are no winners here. The taxpayer, again, is the loser."

Old Orchard Beach's latest woes are, as these things tend to be, complicated.

But at its barest essence, this looming political Armageddon began when the aforementioned four-councilor majority voted in early March to part ways with Town Manager Mark Pearson -- the town's fourth manager in the past decade.

Pearson's heave-ho was preceded by a laundry list of internal squabbles that included Public Works Director Bill Robertson being investigated for allegedly threatening to "shoot" Pearson. Robertson, who was fired by Pearson only to be rehired in a 4-3 vote by the council, later claimed it was all a misunderstanding -- he actually wanted to "moon" Pearson.

But we digress. Suffice it to say that Pearson's dismissal didn't go over well with the council's three-member minority, along with a sizable chunk of the local citizenry.

In fact, council meetings since have devolved routinely into nasty exchanges not just between the two council factions, but also with irate citizens in the audience. Topsham attorney John Richardson, representing Pearson in a lawsuit to get his job back, will never forget one recent session that came as close to outright revolution as he's ever witnessed.

"It was the most raw form of democracy I've ever seen in my life," said Richardson last week, recalling how the agenda (not to mention Roberts Rules of Parliamentary Procedure) disappeared beneath a tsunami of name calling, finger pointing and promises that the council's days were numbered.

It was no idle threat: No sooner had critics of MacDonald, Bolduc, Furtado and Mailhot set about circulating their recall petitions when a second citizens group, Taxpayers for Truth, set its sights on Coleman, Dayton and Quinn.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)