June 13, 2013

Panhandling solutions imperfect

- I gave a panhandler a buck Tuesday morning.

I'm not sure why -- I readily admit I ignore Portland's ever-growing legion of median-strip dwellers far more often than I lower the driver's window and pass them a few coins or a dollar bill.

But it was raining hard and I figured if this hapless soul was willing to stand there and get soaked at the corner of Marginal Way and Franklin Street, he deserved some small reward for his effort.

"I'm a painter and I haven't been able to find any work," he said when I asked what had brought him to this point.

Then I asked if he knew the City Council's Public Safety Health and Human Services Committee would meet that very evening to debate whether median strips are appropriate places to ask other people for money.

"You mean they're not going to let us be here anymore?" he asked, peering through the drops falling from his clear-plastic poncho.

"Maybe not," I replied.

The light turned green. He shrugged and prepared to greet the next round of oncoming traffic. I went on with my day, not sure if my dollar would help him, hurt him or do something in between.

The truth is, I'm all over the map when it comes to panhandling.

One minute, I nod in agreement with friends (mostly business types) who say the multitudes standing with their cardboard signs at every gateway to downtown Portland are a blight on the city's image and, with summer at our doorstep, a repellent to tourists in search of the way life should be.

The next, I agree with the public safety advocates who argue that it's only a matter of time before someone -- a panhandler, a motorist -- gets creamed in a spot never intended for this type of transaction.

Then along come these occasional moments when impulse strikes and I'm holding out a soggy dollar -- not because I truly believe it will solve anything, but because at this particular time in this particular place, it simply feels like the right thing to do.

Enter "Have a Heart, Give Smart," a soon-to-be-launched effort by Portland's downtown business community to nurture my inner do-gooder and, at the same time, send all those panhandlers packing. A win-win, you might say -- assuming you're not a panhandler.

On a separate but parallel track, we have a proposed ordinance (the second in as many years) that would make it illegal for any person to "stand, sit, stay, drive or park" on a "paved or planted area of public right-of-way, dividing a street or highway into lanes according to the direction of travel." Put more simply, that guy who gratefully accepted my buck Tuesday morning would be booted from the median but allowed on the nearby street corner.

Good ideas? Bad ideas?

Let's discuss.

"You hear the voices as well as I do. There are people in town who say, 'Sweep the bums off the street!' or 'Don't feed the animals!'" said Chris O'Neil of the Portland Community Chamber in an interview Tuesday. "But most people in Portland, including the chamber, don't talk that way or even think that way. We are undoubtedly a compassionate community."

No argument there. But O'Neil, the driving force behind the "Have a Heart" initiative, says it would make far more sense if that compassion were funneled through a single conduit to all of Portland's neediest, not just that man or woman on the corner whose sign may or may not be telling the real story.

"Have a Heart," still in its final planning stages, will work something like this: Those looking to upgrade their daily karma can simply drop their spare change (or bills) into one of many collection boxes in participating businesses around the city, or in brightly painted parking meters donated by the city and installed in locations (well away from the curb) with high pedestrian traffic.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)