Sunday, December 8, 2013
Elderly ladies are portrayed sitting at a kitchen table in Republican 2nd Congressional District hopeful Kevin Raye’s latest campaign ad, and they aren’t fans of U.S. Rep. Mike Michaud, his challenger.
ABOUT TRUTH TEST
TRUTH TEST is a feature of MaineToday Media's campaign coverage in which we cast a critical eye on the truthfulness of advertising and public comments by political candidates and groups.
TO SEE this ad, click here
FOR A ROUNDUP of all the Truth Tests we've conducted during the 2012 campaign season, click here.
They aren’t that well-informed, either. The ad’s statements of fact, taken together, make the ad half-true.
The actresses hit Michaud on a taxpayer-funded car lease that created controversy earlier in the year, his support of President Obama’s health care reform and a vote he made that would have raised the tax on retirement dividends. Another claim, that Michaud voted against small businesses and farmers, is an interpretation of votes collected by a group endorsing Raye, which we aren’t checking.
“Now, we’re paying almost $800 a month for his car lease.”
This claim is legitimate. In August, the Portland Press Herald published a list of congresspeople leasing in-district vehicles in 2011.
Michaud was on it, paying $795 per month for a lease. He was one of 82 representatives on the list.
Rules for the reimbursable car leases are relatively specific. Only the congressperson and his or her staff are allowed to drive the car, which must meet certain emissions standards. Certain expenses related to driving the car can also be reimbursed, including gas, maintenance, wear and tear and registration fees.
Peter Chandler, Michaud’s Washington chief of staff, said the congressman still has the lease, which the office determined was a cheaper way of paying for in-district transportation than any other way. He has said that the lease is cheaper than reimbursing Michaud and a staff member for mileage would be.
Verdict: Michaud maintains the lease. While it doesn’t look uncommon or improper, it’s a fact.
We rate this statement true.
“Michaud also voted for Obamacare that cuts our Medicare.”
No matter how much Republicans — from presidential nominee Mitt Romney to Raye — suggest the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act cuts Medicare benefits, it won’t be genuine. It slows future growth in the program and adds some new benefits.
As we’ve noted in a past Truth Test, the health care legislation championed by President Obama does reduce Medicare spending by $716 billion between 2013 and 2022, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
But $260 billion of that savings come from reduced growth in payments to health care providers, the CBO has said. Payments to Medicare Advantage plans, a Bush administration-era private insurance piece of Medicare, will also be scaled back with future reimbursement levels tied to merit-based metrics, the Washington Post has said.
The law stipulates that guaranteed Medicare benefits can't be rolled back, FactCheck.org has said. It’s already strengthened benefits for many.
In August, the Obama administration’s Department of Health and Human Services announced that in 2012’s first half, more than 1 million Medicare recipients a total of $687 million on prescription drugs, due to changes in the law.
Verdict: There’s no specificity in the ad, just the language of a “cut.” This number is misleading, especially the way the ladies portray it in Raye’s ad. Slowing of future growth isn’t a cut, and benefits have been expanded.
We rate this statement false.
“And he voted to raise the tax on our retirement dividends.”
Michaud voted against a Republican plan that would hold the line on this tax for everyone.
But he voted for a Democratic plan that would hold the line for everyone but those making more than $250,000. So this is a classic political half-truth, keying on one vote and not another.
(Continued on page 2)