Sunday, March 9, 2014
By Colin Woodard firstname.lastname@example.org
School officials across Maine reacted with relief and confusion Monday to Gov. Paul LePage's decision to make Hewlett-Packard the preferred supplier of computers for the state's middle school laptop program.
The decision, which allows school districts to choose their own laptop or tablet providers, ends Apple's decade-long run of supplying laptops to all of Maine's seventh- and eighth-graders. But it has created some uncertainty for local school officials, who are scrambling to determine what technology they can afford to use next fall.
After weeks of delay, the governor selected a package based on the HP ProBook 4440 -- a Microsoft Windows-based laptop -- from a field of five finalists, even though it was more expensive and received a lower score from contract evaluators than Apple's iPad 32-gigabyte tablet proposal. Students currently use Apple MacBooks.
In a news release issued Saturday morning, LePage erroneously said this was "the lowest-priced proposal," while emphasizing that Windows is "commonly used in the workplace in Maine" and that it is "important that our students are using technology that they will see and use in the workplace."
As part of the program, the state provides learning devices free of charge to all seventh- and eighth-grade public school students and their teachers. Many of Maine's school districts have chosen to lease additional devices for high school students at the reduced rates negotiated by the state.
Although he awarded the bid to the HP laptop, LePage also said that schools can choose from any of the five finalists if they wish. The state would pay for seventh- and eighth-graders' devices up to the negotiated price of the ProBook -- $285.77 per year, including networking and support services -- and the school districts would pay the rest.
"The governor wasn't comfortable moving forward with tablets knowing what he knew about Maine business and what they use," said LePage's spokeswoman, Adrienne Bennett. "But we are allowing the flexibility for schools to make that choice on their own. If they are committed to Apple and they don't want to make that change, they certainly have that option."
On Monday, school districts and administration officials were both scurrying to understand what the decision meant. It was not clear whether the vendors of the other four devices -- Apple's iPad and MacBook Air laptop, HP's ElitePad tablet, and CTL's 2go Convertible Classmate NL4 tablet -- will agree to offer them at the same discounted rates they had offered on the assumption they would be, in effect, the state's sole contractor.
Earlier in the day, the governor's office said the other four devices would be priced at a less advantageous rate, described under the request for proposals as "tier 2." This would represent a considerable cost difference. In the case of the iPad proposal, annual per-user costs would jump from $266 to $410.
However, by midafternoon the administration had shifted its position, asserting that it expects all devices to be available at the most favorable "tier 1" pricing.
The potential cost differences to school districts are enormous. A school district wishing to use the Apple iPad for 200 middle school students and 400 high school students would need to come up with $106,400 annually under tier 1 pricing but nearly $189,000 under tier 2 rates.
Administration officials appear to be playing hardball in their negotiations for the contract, which is likely worth in excess of $100 million. Department of Education spokesman David Connerty-Marin said the final prices would be determined in negotiations over the next few days, but that the state would not accept prices higher than tier 1.
"We can't force them to sign at this rate, but I would be surprised if they walked away from the market," he said. "Our job as we negotiate the final contract is to get the best possible deal we can, and for that matter we could negotiate something lower than the award prices for some of these, or get other improvements."
(Continued on page 2)