October 2, 2011

When Maine went dry

Maine's distinction as the birthplace of Prohibition earns it a role in a Ken Burns documentary.

By Kelley Bouchard kbouchard@pressherald.com
Staff Writer

The hard-won legislation was so groundbreaking, so controversial, it was known across the nation and beyond as "the Maine law."

click image to enlarge

The Rum Room in Portland City Hall, where confiscated liquor and liquor-making equipment was stored, in an image from a postcard mailed in the early 1900s.

click image to enlarge

Officials remove illegal liquor from a ship docked at the Grand Trunk Wharf in Portland Harbor in the 1920s. Prohibition became law nationwide with the 18th Amendment in 1919.

Press Herald file photo

Additional Photos Below

WATCH IT

"PROHIBITION" will air on MPBN, Channel 10 in the Portland area, at 8 tonight.

In 1851, Maine became the first state to ban the manufacture and sale of alcoholic beverages, though an exception for "medicinal, mechanical and manufacturing purposes" kept many liquor wagons rolling.

Portland Mayor Neal Dow, the so-called "Father of Prohibition," pushed the law through the Legislature, became a leader in the national temperance movement and ran for president on the Prohibition Party ticket in 1880.

Many states and other countries followed Maine's lead, culminating with the passage of the 18th Amendment in 1919 and the start of national Prohibition the following year. Lawmakers and temperance leaders might have taken a harder look at Maine's experience and avoided the widespread pitfalls that prompted the national law's repeal 13 years later.

Many Mainers flouted the state's dry law, concocting liquor at home and selling it to neighbors in "kitchen bars." Farmers continued the age-old practice of turning apples and other fruits into hard cider and wine. Tavern owners saw fines as a cost of doing business. Pharmacies and groceries sold alcohol legally as medicines and flavor extracts. The Portland Rum Riot of 1855, when an angry mob gathered outside City Hall, left one man dead and seven injured.

"What happened in Portland and in Maine was a microcosm of what would happen across the country," said Earle Shettleworth, Maine's state historian. "When Prohibition passed, people immediately began to find ways to circumvent it."

Maine's bumpy history as the birthplace of Prohibition and a stronghold of the temperance movement will be featured in "Prohibition," a three-part PBS documentary series that starts tonight.

The series was directed by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick, award-winning makers of films about the Civil War, baseball, jazz and World War II.

The documentary covers the development of drinking habits in America, from its founding when rum was the beverage of choice for many through the flood of European immigrants in the late 1800s.

It explores the motivating factors that led to Prohibition and its links to women's suffrage, changing social mores, anti-immigrant fervor, organized crime and advances in the legal system.

Researchers for the film spent several days at the Maine Historical Society in Portland in 2009, poring over photographs, newspapers and advertisements from the 1800s and early 1900s. The society has an extensive collection of Prohibition-related materials, which were featured in a 1998 exhibit, "Rum, Riot and Reform: Maine and the History of American Drinking."

"The film's researchers went through tons of photographs and other ephemera, looking for visuals that would capture the era," said Jamie Rice, public services librarian at the society. "Ultimately, they selected 14 images. It was a lot of work for 14 images."

They selected photographs of Mainers at work, on the streets and in churches. One shot captured the H.H. Hay Apothecary on Congress Street in Portland. They also chose the following headline from The State of Maine newspaper in Portland on June 5, 1855: "Atrocious Outrage! Citizens fired upon by order of Mayor Dow. One Man Killed, Seven Wounded!" The shocking story ran on page 2.

"In most of the research I've done, Prohibition wasn't on the front page," Rice said. "When national Prohibition passed, surprisingly it was buried in the back of newspapers. You'd think you'd want to let people know they couldn't drink anymore."

In Maine, as in most of the nation, the temperance movement was a complicated issue born from frustration with widespread drinking as a cultural norm and the socioeconomic problems it caused, including poverty and domestic violence. In the early 1800s, when the city had about 9,000 residents, there were more than 200 licensed liquor establishments in downtown Portland. The world's first Total Abstinence Society was founded in Portland in 1815 and a statewide organization of local temperance groups formed in 1834.

"It was a reflection of the cultures we came from in Europe," Shettleworth said. "Alcohol was used to reward workers throughout the workday, so it was part of the industrial workplace. When ministers went visiting, they would go from house to house, expecting to be served a drink at each one. By the time they got home, they were very well lubricated."

Temperance leaders focused on alcohol as the source of society's ills. Many of them, like Dow, positioned themselves on a religious and moral high ground and expected others to climb the hill. Some were also abolitionists who wanted to end slavery.

As more immigrants came, expanding the working class and diversifying public drinking habits, the temperance movement grew more political.

"Neal Dow believed if the sin is huge, then the salvation must be strict," said Herb Adams, a Portland historian. "At stake was the moral well-being of mankind, starting in Portland, Maine, of course. Alcohol was the central issue and everything else got tangled in it."

By the time the Maine law passed in 1851, temperance groups had been fighting for liquor reform for 25 years. It was repealed in 1856, following the Portland Rum Riot, when opponents of the law stormed City Hall because they thought Dow was selling liquor stored in the basement. The law was re-enacted in various forms and eventually folded into the state constitution in 1885.

"They kept tinkering with the law, but it never really worked," said Bill Berry, a reference assistant at the Maine Historical Society who worked on the 1998 exhibit.

The Maine law not only laid the foundation for national Prohibition, it also broke legal ground by establishing a standard for justifiable search and seizure, wrote Wesley Oliver, a law professor at Widener University, in the Maine Bar Journal.

The law allowed a magistrate to issue a warrant to search for liquor in a building if at least three complainants had probable cause to believe alcohol was there.

An additional provision, drafted by Portland lawyer Edward Fox, required at least one of the complainants to swear and provide evidence that he had actually witnessed the sale of liquor at the house. The law made it possible for police to investigate crimes on behalf of victims or witnesses in a way that would stand up in court.

The Maine law remained in effect until the repeal of national Prohibition in 1933, amid the Great Depression.

Through the years, it was celebrated, tolerated and reviled. During Portland's three-day centennial celebration in 1886, several events featured temperance songs and Dow delivered a long, glowing account of society's improvement under the Maine law.

"The wages of labor are now saved and devoted to other purposes than the purchase of drink," Dow said, "(in) better public buildings, (in) better ways of living, in multiplied and enlarged industries, and in prosperous, thrifty, happy homes."

As pressure for national Prohibition grew, President Theodore Roosevelt pointed to Maine's experience as reason to think twice, according to the "Text-Book of True Temperance," published by the United States Brewers' Association in 1911.

"The state of Maine has been trying prohibition for 60 years," Roosevelt said. "That is long enough to try anything. What has been accomplished in the state? The American people down in Alabama, Tennessee and other states are waiting to hear the facts."

The nation went ahead with the "noble experiment" of Prohibition despite Maine's example, and the temperance movement continued in Maine for decades after the federal law was repealed. Ben Bubar of China, then superintendent of the Christian Civic League of Maine, ran for president on the Prohibition Party ticket in 1975. The Maine Women's Christian Temperance Union, located in the Neal Dow House at 714 Congress St. in Portland, is the last group of its kind in the state and has about 20 members.

The PBS series comes during a period of rejuvenated interest in the Prohibition era, including HBO's award-winning dramatic series, "Boardwalk Empire." The interest doesn't surprise Shettleworth, the state historian. It was a pivotal time in America and encompassed issues far beyond alcohol. But the intrigue of the forbidden is paramount.

"It's only natural for people to be fascinated by things that they are denied," Shettleworth said. "You tell me I can't have something and of course I want it."

Staff Writer Kelley Bouchard can be contacted at 791-6328 or at:

kbouchard@pressherald.com

 

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors


Additional Photos

click image to enlarge

Neal Dow, the so-called "Father of Prohibition"

  


Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)