July 12, 2010

Letters to the editor, July 12. 2010
'Hockey stick' creator rebuts critic

In a piece published in your paper on July 9 you allowed an individual named Dave Irons to do a grave disservice to your readers by making false and defamatory statements about me and my climate scientist colleagues.

click image to enlarge

Penn State climate scientist Michael Mann writes to say a Maine Voices column last Friday protrayed him and his work incorrectly.

Penn State photo

Mr. Irons' claim that global warming has been "almost entirely discredited" demonstrates an embarrassing lack of awareness of the overwhelming consensus behind the fact that humans are influencing the climate. Mr. Irons appeals to false allegations based on out-of-context quoting and cherry-picking of words and phrases from stolen private e-mails to level the false and defamatory claim that climate scientists have been engaged in an effort to "hide" data.

Such claims have now been dismissed by five different independent reviews in the United States and the Unied Kingdom. To individuals such as Mr. Irons, such findings of course are simply part of a grand international conspiracy. The more authoritatively his claims have been debunked, the grander of course the conspiracy must be!

Mr. Irons makes the specific defamatory allegation against me that work by my colleagues and me reconstructing past temperature trends is "fraudulent."

Both the U.S. National Academy of Sciences, and my university, Penn State University, have exonerated me of the false allegations against me by climate change deniers like Mr. Irons. The National Academy of Sciences has furthermore affirmed my research findings, as have dozens of other independent groups of scientists.

Mr. Irons promotes the standard climate change denier talking point that climate scientists are making "billions" of dollars for their work.

Almost all government research funds obtained by climate scientists (and all other scientists for that matter) go to funding research, field work, etc. and the support of graduate students, post-doctoral researchers, and staff. Scientists do not financially benefit themselves from these grants.

That is to be contrasted with a handful of professional climate change deniers who are indeed typically compensated personally by industry front groups for their attacks against the science of climate change. In an Orwellian twist of logic, Mr. Irons actually cites several such individuals in support of his position.

Readers interested in the truth behind the science, rather than the falsehoods and smears perpetuated by people like Mr. Irons, should consult the scientist-run website, www.realclimate.org, or scientifically-based books on the topic like my "Dire Predictions: Understanding Global Warming."

It is ironic that Mr. Irons accuses scientists (including myself) of dishonesty.

It is those like Mr. Irons who spread false information about science and scientists -- whether knowingly, or by simply uncritically parroting the disinformation of others -- who do the greatest harm to the public discourse on vital issues such as climate change.

Michael E. Mann

Professor, Department of Meteorology, Penn State University

Director, Penn State Earth System Science Center

State College, Pa.

Everything was great on Eastern Prom July 4

On behalf of the 50,000-plus who attended or otherwise enjoyed the 2010 Patriotic Pops on the Eastern Prom, thank you to the sponsors who made this happen. The Maine Red Claws, Quirk Chevrolet, Portland Newspapers, Wright Express, and all of the others.

Your dedication to making this an A-plus event was highly successful. The Portland Symphony Orchestra was spectacular.

Thank you, and here is a toast to the beginning of something truly spectacular!

James D. Konkel

Cape Elizabeth

James Phinney Baxter would have loved to be on Eastern Promenade on Sunday night.

I sat on my porch and thought of the people that made Eastern Promenade Park a reality. James Phinney Baxter was the driving force in the creation of Eastern Promenade Park when he was the mayor of Portland between 1895 and 1905.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)