Politics

September 17, 2012

Truth Test: Republican ad fails to get facts, period

It attacks two Senate candidates: independent Angus King over a loan he didn't benefit from and Democrat Cynthia Dill over bills that died before affecting taxpayers.

By Michael Shepherd mshepherd@centralmaine.com
Staff Writer

The TV ad paid for by the National Republican Senatorial Committee hits independent U.S. Senate candidate Angus King and Democratic candidate Cynthia Dill and has a couple of the most spurious claims seen so far in the campaign season here.

click image to enlarge

ABOUT TRUTH TEST

TRUTH TEST is a regular feature of MaineToday Media's campaign coverage in which we cast a critical eye on the truthfulness of advertising and public comments by political candidates.

VIEW
 all Election 2012 Truth Tests.

It uses speculation against King's history in the wind power business, criticizing him for loans that documents show he wasn't around to benefit from.

It says Dill, a state senator from Cape Elizabeth, "left taxpayers the bill with her liberal policies," citing two legislative bills she sponsored. But the bills never made it into law. Another claim, about Dill supporting policies advocated by President Barack Obama, is right.

"King used his political connections to get a taxpayer-backed loan for his windmill business. The press says King's loan was so sketchy, Congress had to investigate."

The ad is referencing Independence Wind LLC, a Maine-based company in which King was a partner until earlier this year, when he sold his share of the company to his then-partner Robert Gardiner, just after announcing his Senate run.

The project referred to is Record Hill in Roxbury, one of two projects Independence Wind was involved in. Record Hill applied for the loan in 2010, got a conditional approval in March 2011, and the U.S. Department of Energy announced the $125 million loan's finalization in August 2011. A congressional committee did criticize that loan. More on that later.

But Gardiner said Independence Wind sold its 10 percent share of Record Hill in January 2011. That's seven months before the loan was granted. King's campaign provided a document showing the Record Hill share was sold Jan. 14, 2011.

Now, we'll tackle the reference to "political connections." A Republican Senatorial Committee official said that was a reference to a 2010 recommendatory letter for the Record Hill project sent by U.S. Rep. Chellie Pingree, D-1st District. The official also noted that King has said he is close friends with Pingree, which is true. But a Pingree spokesman said King wasn't involved in asking for the letter.

"Rob Gardiner called me, I talked to our staff, we wrote the letter for Chellie and never communicated with Angus on that," said Pingree spokesman Willy Ritch. "I would point out that this is the kind of thing Congresswoman Pingree does all the time. She supports the wind industry and thinks it should grow."

Pingree's husband, S. Donald Sussman, is majority share owner of MaineToday Media, which publishes the Portland Press Herald, Kennebec Journal and Morning Sentinel and other media outlets in Maine.

Now, for the congressional blowback: A staff report from the Republican-controlled House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform criticized the loan to Record Hill, among many other government loans.

The committee was motivated to examine Department of Energy loans by the failure of Solyndra, a solar power company that got a $527 million government loan and went bankrupt. Gardiner has told MaineToday Media that Record Hill is paying back the loan, so taxpayers aren't on the hook for money so far.

Verdict: Since King's former firm sold its small share of the Record Hill project in January 2011, before the loan was issued, it's hard to say King got "his" company a loan. Pingree's office also denies that King was involved in getting her letter of recommendation for the loan. From the information we can gather, there's no support for the Republican committee's claims. They simply didn't compile the sourcing to make them.

We rate this statement false.

"Dill gave taxpayers the bill with her liberal policies."

As the voiceover says this, two Dill-sponsored legislative bills are cited at the bottom of the screen.

Sure, Dill's liberal. But there's a problem: Both bills cited by the Republican Senatorial Committee were killed. Their swift deaths, without even a roll call vote, made it difficult for them to give taxpayers the bill for anything. That makes this claim outright dishonest.

One of the bills, L.D. 469, would have mandated out-of-state retailers not required to collect sales tax to notify Maine purchasers of their obligation to pay sales tax in Maine.

The other bill, L.D. 826, would have allowed municipalities to impose their own sales tax of 3 percent or less by local referendum. The revenue would have been split three ways: 50 percent would go to the municipality, 25 percent to the county the municipality is in and 25 percent to the state's General Fund.

Verdict: There's a good chance these Dill-floated laws would have been unpopular in many circles. But you can't blame Dill for costing taxpayers money when bills you're blaming her for didn't come close to passing.

We rate this statement false.

"Democrat Dill supports Obama's tax increases and Obama's stimulus."

Dill supports President Obama on almost every political issue she's been asked about. This claim is true.

We asked her campaign about her support for Obama's plans in an overarching way.

"Yes, I supported the Obama stimulus plan that rescued the economy from the brink of Bush-era financial collapse," Dill said in a statement. "And I do support Obama's proposal to end tax breaks on people earning more than $250,000 per year."

Verdict: It's no surprise that Dill supports these policies, as she's an avowed progressive.

We rate this statement true.

The first statement of fact, involving King, isn't borne out by the Republican Senatorial Committee's sourcing, and information we gathered on the subject finds it can't pass muster. Their shoddy sourcing on Dill costing taxpayers money is just as bad, citing dead bills Mainers don't have to worry about. Their last statement, about Dill's support of Obama, is true and certainly no news flash.

We rate this ad mostly false.

Michael Shepherd can be contacted at 621-5632 or at:

mshepherd@mainetoday.com

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors




Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)


Blogs

More PPH Blogs