A state lawmaker says he will propose legislation to give judges more sentencing flexibility in murder cases, in response to a case in which the killer strangled a teenager from Portland, then decapitated and burned her body.

Rep. Michael Celli, R-Brewer, said he will introduce the bill at the request of a Brewer woman who was related to Zoe Sarnacki.

Sarnacki, 18, was killed by Chad Gurney in May 2009. He was sentenced last month to 50 years for murder and 10 years for arson. He couldn’t receive a life sentence because of strict sentencing guidelines.

Gurney, 29, was the poster child for a life sentence, said Laurie Morris, Sarnacki’s aunt. Even though Gurney will either die in prison or be very old when he gets out, Morris said something’s not right if the judge was precluded from sentencing him to life.

“I’m doing this for myself and for Zoe and for other families, so if this happens again, at least the person won’t be able to get out of jail,” Morris said. “Chad Gurney, I don’t care if he’s 79 years old or 100, he can still get out. He’s a dangerous, cold, calculated murderer. It’s the principle of the thing.”

In sentencing Gurney, Superior Court Justice Roland Cole said he couldn’t recall another case in Maine that compared to Gurney’s “horrific” actions.

But he was bound by a 1990 state supreme court ruling saying a judge can’t impose a life sentence unless the murder is accompanied by “aggravating circumstances” such as premeditation, multiple deaths, lengthy criminal background, killing a law enforcement officer or “torture, sexual abuse or other extreme cruelty.”

Although the facts of the Gurney case were hideous, the judge said torture or extreme cruelty didn’t apply because Sarnacki was already dead when he abused the body.

Celli said the case illustrates the need to give judges more leeway in murder cases. Other murder convictions have drawn longer sentences, he said, even though they weren’t nearly as gruesome.

“Some people, by the fact of how they commit the murder, have no business being among the general public,” said Celli, who plans to introduce his bill this spring or when the Legislature reconvenes next year.

Deputy Attorney General Bill Stokes, who is in charge of murder cases for the state, said he understands why some people think judges need more flexibility in giving life sentences in murder cases.

“Our office has generally gotten significant sentences when they’re not life,” Stokes said. “But I’d have to look at the wording of the legislation before I could comment on it.”


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or to participate in the conversation. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.