Gov. Paul LePage launched a phone campaign this week seeking to control damage caused by his recent statement that categorized Social Security as welfare – a statement that could be a liability for him among senior citizens, an important voting bloc in Maine.

The effort by LePage’s re-election campaign follows the controversy sparked by a news release issued by the governor’s office last week, while he was on a trade mission in China.

The Portland Press Herald quoted from the release, which characterized Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and unemployment insurance benefits as forms of “welfare, pure and simple.”

This week’s minute-long automated call features a pre-recorded message from LePage, in which he blames “liberal newspapers” and “liberal politicians” for the controversy and highlights his policies that have benefited seniors.

“I do not believe Social Security is welfare. Unfortunately, liberal newspapers, owned by a billionaire who opposes me, with liberal politicians Michael Michaud and Eliot Cutler, presented you with false information,” LePage says in the call.

Listen to Gov. LePage’s pre-recorded message:


LePage doesn’t explicitly identify the Portland Press Herald, which first reported the story and whose majority owner is S. Donald Sussman, the financier and philanthropist who is married to U.S. Rep. Chellie Pingree, D-Maine.

The phone campaign underscores the importance of winning senior citizens’ votes in Maine, which has the second-highest proportion of residents 65 and older and the highest proportion of baby boomers in the United States.

According to U.S. News and World Report, 76 percent of Maine seniors voted in the 2010 elections, second only to Washington state and well above the U.S. averages of 61 percent for senior citizens and 46 percent for all voters.

Maine’s turnout for voters of all ages in 2010 was 57 percent.

A poll conducted for the Press Herald by the University of New Hampshire Survey Center from June 12-18 showed Michaud, the Democratic candidate, with a slight lead among senior citizens. Forty-six percent of all respondents said welfare does more harm than good, and 41 percent said welfare recipients don’t need it.

LePage has made welfare reform a central issue in his campaign. Michaud recently called for the creation of an Office of Inspector General in the state Department of Health and Human Services to root out fraud and abuse. And Cutler, an independent candidate, has talked about the need to make it easier for people to make the transition from welfare to work.


This week’s robocalls were paid for by LePage’s re-election campaign. Brent Littlefield, LePage’s political adviser, would not provide additional information about the calls, including the cost, the number being made or who is being called.

LePage’s Social Security statement came as his administration defended Maine’s economic performance in light of newly released federal data ranking Maine’s personal-income growth for the first quarter of 2014 as 39th nationally and last in New England. One of the biggest reasons the Bureau of Economic Analysis cited for the low ranking was Maine’s refusal to expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act.

In its news release on June 25, the LePage administration recalculated Maine’s personal income growth by removing Medicaid and other “transfer receipts,” which include Social Security and unemployment insurance benefits. The release quoted the governor, who opposes the Affordable Care Act, as saying, in part: “It doesn’t matter what liberals call these payments, it is welfare, pure and simple.”

LePage’s office sought to clarify his statement the next day, saying that he was referring only to Medicaid as welfare. But Michaud and Cutler pounced on the governor, calling the remark an insult to Maine’s senior citizens.

In this week’s robocalls, LePage takes aim at Michaud.

“Michael Michaud knowingly and deliberately falsified what I said,” LePage says. “I have personally paid into Social Security for more than four decades. Together, we all have family and friends who rely on Social Security. I have always fought to preserve and to protect Social Security.”


LePage continues: “Other politicians tried to tax Social Security – I opposed them. I helped reform deductions for senior citizen pensions, which saved seniors $20 million annually. Social Security is a contract with the American people who paid into the system. As your governor, I will not default on promises to our seniors.”

Alex Willette, LePage’s campaign spokesman, said in an email that LePage used the robocalls because he “wanted to speak directly to the people.”

When asked to explain the governor’s statement that Michaud “knowingly and deliberately falsified” his words, Willette said the statement “speaks for itself.”

Lizzy Reinholt, spokeswoman for the Michaud campaign, accused LePage of “backtracking” after realizing that his views aren’t held by most Mainers.

“Gov. LePage’s press release speaks for itself,” Reinholt said in an email. “Now that he’s realized his belief that Social Security is welfare is completely out of touch with the values and views of the people of Maine, he’s trying to backtrack. He can’t run from it. It’s right there in black and white.”

In a written statement, Cutler said the governor bears the responsibility for his statement.

“This is the kind of mess a governor creates when he calls everything he doesn’t like ‘welfare’ and everyone who disagrees with him a ‘liberal,’ ” Cutler said. “Now he’s spending time and money trying to clean up his mess. Chaos has become the hallmark of the LePage administration. Maine needs a governor who is serious about creating jobs and growing our economy. This is just another unfortunate distraction from the important work that needs to be done.”

Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.