President Donald Trump and Elon Musk’s policy pursuits are unpopular if approached piece by piece. They’re ingested more willfully together because it fits a narrative.

Almost no Americans support executive orders repealing price caps on medication, enabling White House employees to become lobbyists or speed permitting dangerous oil drilling expansion to the detriment of Alaska. The toxicity of these and other orders is made palatable by a narrative that President Trump and his team has crafted: SAFE. SECURITY. STRENGTH. REEMERGENCE.

It’s understandable. Regardless of its accuracy, that is the narrative.

The problem with the “opposition,” then, is an absence of a clear narrative. The most popular office-holding politicians in the country are those who confidently support antithetical measures, such as Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz and Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders. Walz and Sanders are notable for their influence and focus most on actual financial gains for their constituents. But officeholders like them are few.

Other people with similar beliefs are not allowed into positions of leadership and are often financially bulldozed out of Congress due to clashes with Bill Clinton-era holdovers of the Democratic Party; these holdovers occupy positions of leadership both formal and informal, such as Rep. Steny Hoyer (elected 1980), Rep. Nancy Pelosi (1986), Sen. Patty Murray (1992) and Sen. Ron Wyden (U.S. Senate in 1996, first elected to the U.S. House in 1980).

They believe their continued reelection is reflective of their depth and understanding. In reality, it comes down to incumbency bias. My ageist, incumbency critique isn’t exclusive to Democrats (see Republicans Mitch McConnell and Chuck Grassley, first elected to the Senate in 1984 and 1980, respectively). However, “Make America Great Again” is inherently a cry to the past, to the elderly. It’s relevant because despite the actual execution of a strategy endangering senior benefits, it still works. It’s a narrative. People will always pick a narrative they understand over a narrative they don’t.

Advertisement

If the goal is to win, seek strategy and advice from people first elected more recently, as opposed to those whose starts in office predate DNA fingerprinting (1984), the World Wide Web (1989) and texting (1992).

To be consistent, Sen. Sanders (elected to the U.S. House 1990, U.S. Senate 2006) is also too old. However, he is the most popular of all mentioned here, all of whom are also too old. Sanders was the first non-Republican senator elected in Vermont since 1850. This was done without super PACs, megadonors or being a registered Democrat. This was due to some name recognition and his constituents believing in him.

It is incorrect to believe there’s a need for non-Trump figures to become TrumpZero or Diet Trumps — office holders who provide a version of fatalistic deregulation and unmitigated harm but with more virtual signaling and hashtags.

The biggest mistake of Maine Rep. Jared Golden is he believes his reelection is vindication of posturing beside Trump. If anything, he should get his act together; he was barely reelected despite spending $7.6 million against Austin Theriault’s $3.6 million. There was $11 million spent by outside groups opposing Theriault, too.

Despite this, and Golden’s career in the public sector (military included, thank you for your service) being over seven times the years of Theriault, Golden won by fewer than 2,800 votes, failing to get enough votes in the first round. He has plenty of work to do if he wants to shore up support for any future ambitions, gubernatorial or otherwise.

If the other option for Americans wants to be a genuine “other option,” candidates need to be united behind a narrative. One way that the mechanism known as the Democratic Party could achieve this is by banning PAC spending in party primary elections. This would ensure that figures and ideas with genuine grassroots popularity would have a chance to win, ensuring the best outcomes. After all, the narrative that everyone wants most is the narrative with a happy ending.

Join the Conversation

Please sign into your Press Herald account to participate in conversations below. If you do not have an account, you can register or subscribe. Questions? Please see our FAQs.

filed under: