3 min read
Eagle Mart, operating out of a shed that was barged onto Chebeague Island, is set to open on June 9. (Courtesy of Mike Makee)

Chebeague Island residents will have a spot to buy groceries after all next year — in the way they’re long familiar with — and with a quirky alternative in the interim.

Doughty’s Island Market, the only store on Chebeague Island and a staple of the community, closed at the end of March after 65 years in business. The closure brought an outpouring of gratitude from the community for its owner, Julie Doughty, who retired after nearly four decades running the market.

The loss of the island’s sole spot to get groceries, prepared food and other daily essentials also sparked anxiety, particularly for older island residents who struggle to bring in groceries regularly from the mainland via ferry.

“This place is the key to survival year round,” said Chebeague Island resident Leila Bisharat, 83, in March.

Islanders huddle on the front porch of Doughty’s Island Market on Chebeague Island on March 31. “This is the gathering place of the island,” Grace Groothoff said. (Daryn Slover/Staff Photographer) Purchase this image

While Julie’s son, Joshua Doughty, thought he might take over the family store someday, he was not ready to run it when his mother retired in March. However, after seeing the impact of its closure on the community, and given his desire to continue his family’s legacy on the island, he announced this month that Doughty’s Island Market will reopen.

“It was a hard decision. I’m a nurse, I have other things going on. But I don’t want to see the store end,” said Joshua Doughty.

Advertisement

He plans to reopen the store in spring 2027, after giving the building a refresh and updating its operating systems. He also wants to continue to work as a nurse with a more flexible schedule, and hopes to hire islanders to staff the market.

“There’s such a need, so I’m doing it,” he said.  “People have been very excited that Doughty’s isn’t closed forever.”

For this summer, Chebeague Island residents and vacationers can check out a temporary store that two college students are running out of a 10-by-16-foot shed.

Cousins Mike Makee and Zach Serrano have been spending summers on Chebeague their whole lives — their great-great-grandfather started coming to the island in 1898 — and Makee’s parents moved there full time five years ago. They’ve never been to Chebeague without going to Doughty’s Island Market.

“It was an absolute staple of the island,” said Makee, 21.  “When it closed down, it was definitely a shock to the island.”

Cousins Zach Serrano, left, and Mike Makee are studying business at Miami University at will open Eagle Market on Chebeague Island this summer. (Courtesy of Mike Makee)

Both are entering their senior year studying business at Miami University in Ohio, and they decided to use what they’ve learned in the classroom on an island in Maine. With $15,000 in startup costs, they barged a pre-built shed out to the island, where it now sits on South Road across from the Slow Bell Cafe.

Dubbing it “Eagle Mart,” a patriotic name for the country’s 250th anniversary and a nod to the bald eagles that nest on Chebeague, they plan to stock the essentials: milk, eggs, chips, flour, beer and wine, batteries and sunscreen.

They were unable to find a spot for the shed in the island’s business zone that had running water and septic, so they will only be able to sell prepackaged food items. Makee has been outfitting the shed with shelves and a counter, while Serrano is finishing an internship and will join the operation shortly.

It won’t be Doughty’s Island Market, said Makee, just something to hold residents over in the meantime.

They initially planned to open Memorial Day weekend, but were still waiting on the town’s final site plan review. They now expect to open on June 9 at 10 a.m.

“Everybody’s excited,” said Makee. “Taking the boat, talking to people, they’re elated there’s going to be groceries back on the island.”

Sophie is a community reporter for Cumberland, Yarmouth, North Yarmouth and Falmouth and previously reported for the Forecaster. Her memories of briefly living on Mount Desert Island as a child drew her...

Join the Conversation

Please your Press Herald account to participate in conversations below. If you do not have an account, you can subscribe here. Questions? Please see our FAQs.