3 min read

The unsettling historical parallel that is increasingly apt likens the present state of global paralysis and economic depression with the early years of the Great Depression.

It is an unsettling parallel because the floundering leadership in Europe of the 1930s and the economic misery that were the result led to extremism of the worst sort. In our historical memory, we may view Nazism as an aberration of extreme evil, but maybe it’s not as aberrant as we think. It wasn’t so long ago that Europeans were establishing concentration camps and carrying out genocide in the former Yugoslavia. Extremism happens when the center does not hold.

Looking back on the early ’30s, we may wish we could shake the complacent leaders of Germany, Britain and France, urging them to get their act together in order to avert unimaginable horror. But they didn’t get their act together. All three nations, having passed through the horror of World War I, were still in the grip of bitter resentments and abject denial. In Italy the fascist Mussolini offered up an extreme alternative, and in 1933 the German government named Hitler chancellor.

People reach for an extreme alternative when all sensible alternatives have failed. In Greece and Spain, unemployment has created a new Great Depression. Polarization is likely to increase. We shouldn’t forget that in the late 1940s Greece experienced a vicious and murderous civil war.

Commonsense solutions exist for our economic challenges, but vested interests also exist. In the United States, if Florida or Arizona suffer excessively because of the bursting of a housing bubble, the system as a whole bolsters them and government benefits, provided by all 50 states, flow to those who suffer. In the European Union, Greece and Spain are suffering, but there is no federal system that automatically cushions their fall. Germans resent bailing out spendthrift Greeks and have imposed a regime of austerity that now threatens to bring down the entire European Union.

Advertisement

The United States cannot assume superior airs in relation to Europe. The vested interests who maintain a paralyzing hold on Congress refuse to allow the government to take commonsense steps to resolve persistent economic and fiscal problems. The failure of our leaders to take constructive action places them in the ranks of the floundering leaders of the early 1930s, clinging to outdated theories as real people suffer. Herbert Hoover, meet Mitt Romney.

The niceties of journalism encourage journalists to take what is called a balanced view, assigning equal blame to both sides for refusing to cooperate. Increasingly, however, writers from the right and left are coming to the conclusion that the balanced view is not accurate, that the Republican Party has been captured by an extreme radical wing, fueled by billionaires’ money and dedicated to the dismantling of the American welfare state. It is their intent to use Congress as a weapon of obstruction, as it was used in the 1950s to obstruct racial progress. It is their intent to destroy the Obama administration.

Obama is no nonpartisan angel. He is a political battler, but he has been continually undermined by actually trying to work with Republicans.

Thus, the United States has its own form of political stasis. We can only hope that we do not require a deepening disaster to recognize the need to abandon self-interest for the common good, to lay down the weapons of partisanship for the kind of pragmatic problem-solving action that can address the pressing demands of struggling economies.

— Rutland (Vt.) Herald



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.