July 24, 2010

Taste & Tell:
Updated menu enhances island inn experience


CHEBEAGUE ISLAND - During the hottest time of the summer you want to escape the heat, even if only for dinner. A meal at an oceanside inn like the Chebeague Island Inn, presiding over the western side of the island and offering good dinners and a fabulous view, is just the ticket.

click image to enlarge

The Chebeague Island Inn’s porch makes an enjoyable dinner setting. An improved menu, under the direction of a new chef, has made the inn a popular destination this summer.

Photo by Kristin Tieg



61 South Road, Chebeague Island. 846-5155; Chebeagueislandinn.com

HOURS: Open for dinner 5:30 to 9 p.m. daily in season (mid-May to mid-October)

Visa, Mastercard, American Express and Discover

$16 to $38

By request

By request – a five-course tasting menu was served with 24-hour notice

KIDS: Children’s menu items served depending on availability

Highly recommended

BAR: Full


A wonderful setting and many well-made dishes featuring Maine-sourced ingredients make dinner at the Chebeague Island Inn memorable.

RATING: ***1/2

A 15-minute ferry ride from Cousins Island will cost $45, including two $15 round-trip tickets and a $15 parking fee in the Chebeague Transportation Co. Route 1 lot, which provides a bus to the ferry dock. The bus leaves 30 minutes before the ferry does.

CAPT. GENE WILLARD, owner of the Island Express Water Taxi, charges $90 for a round-trip from Portland that takes 15 minutes each way. The fee can be split among six.

CASCO BAY LINES’ mail-boat run, the cheapest method at $11.05 round-trip, takes an hour one way and stops at a dock almost five miles from the inn, where the inn van will pick you up.

Rating is based on a five-star scale. It is the policy of the Maine Sunday Telegram to visit an establishment twice if the first dining experience was unsatisfactory.

But first you have to get there, and that will cost you extra (see attached box for info).

Casey Prentice bought the inn with his parents, Richard and Gerry Prentice, at the end of January. The inn opened on May 14 with a new chef, Justin Rowe, who has cooked at Fore Street in Portland, at White Barn Inn and On the Marsh in Kennebunk, and at 555 in Portland.

Prentice says he has focused on improving the menu to draw visitors. One hundred dinner guests, in addition to overnight guests, have been dining there every night of the week this summer.

The lobby is paneled with dark-stained beaded board, as all oceanside inns in Maine used to be. The wide covered porch wrapping two sides of the inn and the building's boxy, 1920s facade give the imagination notice -- this will be an old-fashioned holiday, whether a few hours or a few days long.

But however much you love architectural preservation, you can be grateful the menu holds up-to-date dishes and a decent range of international wines.

With a reservation (essential for this excursion), we were seated at a table on the screened porch, rolled-up plastic curtains ready for rain or cool wind.

Naia Verdejo 2008 from Rueda, Spain ($27), with hints of kumquat and pineapple, was perfect with the Hudson Valley foie gras torchon, a salty, dense piece of molded foie gras. Medjool date and honey in the comb sat alongside, their sweetness and similar creamy textures harmonizing with the foie.

The verdejo was also a hit with the smoked hake salad ($12), called fish and chips on the menu. Lightly dressed new greens and deep-gold house potato chips with lots of crunch completed that appetizer, a good choice when overlooking the sea.

Descendientes De Jose Palacios Petalos 2008 (not the 2007 on the wine list) from Bierzo, Spain ($38), with its deep-red color and peppery flavor, paired perfectly with venison carpaccio ($14) a gamey, intense appetizer touched with white truffle oil and chopped egg gribiche and three toast triangles.

That wine also made good sense with the ribeye ($36), an enormous steak from Archer's Angus in Richmond. Black truffle sauce heightened its beefy flavor with earthy funk, and the cooking of the meat was equally correct -- rare and juicy throughout the interior and crusted with a deep-brown grilled exterior.

But the "melted" leeks promised in the menu were tough and nowhere near a state of melt, and fried gnocchi were dry, resembling browned stale bread.

Seared scallops ($28) presented the kitchen's confident take on protein, again with brown-gold exteriors and tenderness within. Forbidden rice, with its chewy texture, worked well with nutty wild mushrooms foraged by Rick Tibbets and fiddleheads, now out of season and off the menu, in brown butter vinaigrette.

Halibut "chowder" in a smoky cream sauce was the least exciting meal, although fingerling potatoes and bacon are likely to hold more allure on a cooler evening.

Leafy greens from Second Wind Farm on Chebeague and the next-door neighbor's lobsters are also found on the menu.

The Sunset Landing menu is served on the open porch with wicker seating, and holds small bites such as lobster corn dogs, devils on horseback, dates stuffed with blue cheese wrapped with bacon, and scallop ceviche.

Monday night is Nostalgia Night and a favorite for local diners, with a $14-to-$17 menu of old-fashioned classics, including New England boiled dinner, sausage lasagna and stuffed pork chops.

It's too bad the peanut butter cup dessert ($9) involved a small oval cake that was dry and tasteless. Chocolate ganache and peanut butter ice cream couldn't redeem the weird dry cake, although they tasted good alone.

But coriander lemon curd in a puff pastry tart ($9) hit all the sensory sweet spots -- well, almost all. Rich, slightly bitter and alluringly aromatic, the curd was excellent, and the pastry was as delicate as spun sugar. Honey and mascarpone made a creamy pillow alongside.

Frozen desserts ($3 per scoop) are made in-house, and recent offerings have included mint chocolate chip, chocolate and vanilla gelato, berry citrus frozen yogurt and raspberry or coconut lime sorbet.

N.L. English is a Portland freelance writer and the author of "Chow Maine: The Best Restaurants, Cafes, Lobster Shacks and Markets on the Coast."


Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)



More PPH Blogs