May 12, 2013

Maine Gardener: The scoop on plants that come through trials with flying colors


One of the best ways to expand your knowledge of flowers is to listen to people who do plant trials. They get all of the new plants, treat them all the same, and see how they survive and produce.

click image to enlarge

“Starman” was called the best perennial geranium by Fine Gardening.

Courtesy photos

“Milkshake” is considered a great echinacea.

Richard Hawke is plant evaluation manager at the Chicago Botanical Garden, and he presented the results on echinacea, perennial geranium, stachys (commonly called lamb's ears or betony) and thalictrum (meadow rue) during a lecture at New England Grows in Boston in February. It is finally warm enough to start planting, so I thought I would give you the results now.

The most important part of the trial is a plant's durability.

"It doesn't matter how pretty the plant is if it isn't going to survive," Hawke said.

Truer words were never spoken.

Hawke said the test garden has a clay-loam soil with a 7.4 pH, which is less acidic than you would find in Maine, and that the plants receive no fertilizer or chemicals.

The trials run for a minimum of four years, but went to seven years for baptisia (another trial he is running), because it takes so long for them to get established. They are watered, and half of them dead-headed to see if that makes any difference.

New echinaceas, or coneflowers, are introduced all the time, and there is a good reason for that.

"Coneflowers are incredibly promiscuous," Hawke said. "If you have a lot of coneflowers in your garden, you are going to get a lot of different kinds of seedlings. It is not that hard to come up with a new coneflower, but it is hard to make it right."

He said in the last couple of years, there has been a great improvement in echinaceas, with the latest of them being a marriage of a great flower and a great plant.

Hawke believes "Pica Bella" is the best pink echinacea. It has been grown for eight years in the trial garden, so you know it will survive.

"It has boat-shaped petals, an upright habit that stays upright, a strong stem and a strong basal mound of foliage," he said.

For the other pinks, "Pink Meadowbrite" has upright facing flowers, which is a positive, and is drought tolerant. "Pink Double Delight" is downgraded for having a week stem, but wins for flower power.

Hawke said white coneflowers get little respect, but there are some great ones.

" 'Milkshake' is one of the best coneflowers -- not just one of the best whites, but one of the best," he said.

Hawke said that in a storm with 80 mph winds, almost every flower in the garden went horizontal, but "Milkshake" barely even moved, and stayed upright.

He also likes "Kim's Mop Head" with some green in the cone, a dwarf plant at only 16 inches.

As a matter of taste, he likes orange and red echinaceas because they draw his eye.

" 'Marmalade' is one that everyone stops to look at," he said. "It has a big, bold bloom."

Hawke said cranesbills, perennial geraniums, had been dominated by "Johnson's Blue" for years and then by "Rozanne," but there are some new varieties.

He said "Brookside" doesn't have as strong a flower as "Johnson's Blue," but it is more upright and doesn't flop around. He noted that it becomes very tall in his home garden. He prunes it after it flowers, and sometimes it will rebloom.

Hawke said Fine Gardening magazine called "Starman" the best of the best. It has pink and purple flowers, grows in full to part shade, and has a distinctive marking on the petals.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)