March 17, 2011

Latest 'Survivor' challenge: Pink underwear

Maine's Ashley Underwood advances despite a team-mate's unwanted attention.

By Meredith Goad
Staff Writer

Wednesday night's episode of "Survivor" opened with Maine's Ashley Underwood getting an unwelcome eyeful.

We Hate Our Tribe
click image to enlarge

Ashley Underwood, left, and Natalie Tenerelli turn away as Phillip Sheppard displays his pink underwear during Wednesday’s episode of “Survivor: Redemption Island.”

CBS Broadcasting Inc.

We Hate Our Tribe
click image to enlarge

Ometepe tribe members Phillip Sheppard, Natalie Tenerelli, Andrea Boehlke, Ashley Underwood and Grant Mattos compete in the “Smoko” challenge during the fifth episode of “Survivor: Redemption Island,” which aired Wednesday night.

CBS Television Network

A teammate in the Ometepe tribe, Phillip "I'm a former government agent" Sheppard, bent over in his infamous pink underwear, flaunting his goodies right in Underwood's face.

"You're seriously hurting my eyes," Underwood complained, turning away and covering her face.

Sheppard seemed oblivious to the effect that his "pink panties," as Boston Rob Mariano calls them, had on his tribe mates.

Later in the episode, while Boston Rob and Grant Mattos watched their former teammate Matt Elrod win the duel on Redemption Island, Sheppard tried to cozy up to the women left behind in camp.

They were having none of it. Sheppard complained that he "can't seem to make an impression on these girls."

"These girls remind me of the crabs, to be honest," he said, referring to the creatures shown skittering sideways across the sand, "especially Natalie and Ashley."

In one of her private interviews on camera, Underwood admitted that she and her BFF Natalie Tenerelli were just pretending to be nice to Sheppard and Andrea Boehlke.

"There's a lot of faking going on," Underwood said, "but that's the name of the game."

Boehlke complained privately that Underwood and Tenerelli aren't doing enough work around camp. She called them superficial, and noted that all they do is talk about their hair and other girly, un-Survivorlike topics.

"What's up, girls?" Boehlke, carrying a hefty load of firewood, called out to Underwood and Tenerelli as they sunbathed on the beach.

At the immunity challenge, host Jeff Probst revealed the week's reward for the winning tribe: a stash of coffee, tea, cream, sugar and honey, and a basketful of pastries. To compete for the reward, each team had to pick a "caller" to guide his or her blindfolded teammates through a maze to pick up puzzle pieces. Once all the pieces were gathered, the caller was responsible for solving a word-phrase puzzle.

The Ometepe tribe chose Boston Rob to be the caller because he's known to be good with puzzles. The Zapatera tribe chose a still-delusional Stephanie Valencia, who keeps saying things like her tribe "got rid of Russell for no reason."

Russell is Russell Hantz, considered one of the best players ever to play the game. He was voted out last week, leaving Valencia and his other ally, Krista Klumpp, to fend for themselves in their tribe.

The Ometepe tribe won immunity, and the pastry reward, because Boston Rob made quick work of the puzzle (which spelled out the phrase "The sweet taste of victory") and because Zapatera's resident hillbilly, Ralph Kiser, couldn't tell his left from his right.

Back at camp, Underwood and her teammates stuffed their faces with the sweets.

"I can't even choose a favorite," Underwood said. "My favorite are muffins. Those muffins are apple-cinnamon or something, and they're soooo good!"

Mr. Pink Underwear offered to hand over some of his pastries if someone would give him a massage. Underwood was aghast: "I was, like, 'I wouldn't give you a massage for a dozen doughnuts, buddy.'"

Boston Rob and Mattos found the next clue to the hidden immunity idol (which Boston Rob has already found but has neglected to tell his tribe) buried in the coffee. Boston Rob switched this clue with the first clue, which he buried with his idol, and gave the first clue to Mattos to make him think he's in on something. "You've got to hustle if you want to make a dollar," Boston Rob said. "Everybody knows that."

At tribal council, the Zapatera tribe's choice came down to Russell's old harem, Valencia or Klumpp. "They are two dead ducks on a lake, waiting for the gunshots," Sarita White said.

In the end, Klumpp was voted off 5-2, with Steve Wright getting two votes. She didn't go before calling out the various sub-alliances within the tribe to stir things up a little.

The previews for next Wednesday hinted that Underwood and Tenerelli will ruffle some tribal feathers with what Probst called "a girl's spa day."

"If you can make yourself feel more comfortable, why not?" Underwood said in the preview.

The cameras showed the women lying on the beach, with Tenerelli seemingly scraping Underwood's armpit. Or something like that.

Whatever it was, it looked just as bad as that pink underwear.

Staff Writer Meredith Goad can be contacted at 791-6332 or at:


Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)