Gordon Weil’s crusade to defeat Question 5, the proposal to establish ranked-choice voting in Maine, has led him to write a Sept. 30 Maine Voices whose headline calls the proposition “costly, complicated (and) undemocratic.” His arguments, however, are inaccurate, demeaning to Maine voters’ intelligence and almost incomprehensible.

Ranked-choice voting is not complicated; it’s just new to some Mainers (despite successful use in Portland’s mayoral elections). That’s why ranked-choice voting supporters created a statewide education campaign to show voters how it will work.

At their orientation parties, attendees vote via ranked-choice ballots on their preferences among four or more similar items (appetizers, beers, etc.). At receptions I attended, none of the 25 to 40 attendees found the concept complicated. As one guest commented, “We make choices like this all the time.”

Weil also falsely wrote that ranked-choice voting supporters claim “that using it will change voter behavior and make us get along better politically.”

The actual claim is that, under ranked-choice voting, candidates will be less likely to indulge in gratuitous mud-slinging because, by doing so, they would risk antagonizing opponents’ supporters and losing potential second-place votes that could help them win.

As for the costs, let me quote Terry Hayes, Maine state treasurer, who has said: “Question 5 proposes the most cost-effective and efficient process to conduct runoffs, when necessary, to restore majority rule in Maine elections. The cost to implement this decision is estimated to be roughly $550,000, significantly less than the alternative – actual runoff elections,” which Weil advocates. Note: This sum is less than Weil’s claimed cost of $910,000.

Weil’s claim that ranked-choice voting is “undemocratic” is an insult to the intelligence of Maine voters who are tired of hearing officials elected by pluralities called illegitimate. If a majority of Mainers chooses ranked-choice voting to fix that, it will be democratic.

Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.