The most galling part of the letter outlining the decision to remove from view a painting at the center of a controversy is when the architect says he looks forward to working with all participating members of Congress for the 2017 Congressional Art Competition.

Really? Why bother?

The student-artist’s work was sacrificed to political pressure and vigilante censorship – and that should alarm anyone who thinks the First Amendment, unlike art, is not a matter of personal taste and choice.

At issue is “Untitled #1,” a painting by Missouri student David Pulphus that depicts racial confrontation with police. It won unanimous approval in the Congressional Art Competition in Missouri’s 1st District last May and, like the more than 400 other entries accepted and approved, was displayed in the U.S. Capitol. For over six months, the painting was viewed by thousands of visitors without incident.

That changed when an alt-right blog and other conservative commentators started a campaign against it, objecting to its imaging of police as animals. Congressional Republicans took it upon themselves to remove it from the wall and give it to Rep. William Lacy Clay, D-Mo., who, in turn, joined with others in the Congressional Black Caucus to have it rehung. Architect of the Capitol Stephen Ayers ordered the artwork removed Tuesday, saying it violates a House ban on subjects of contemporary political controversy.

If that determination had been made when the painting was first reviewed (and approved), it might have carried some credibility. But other paintings can be seen as dealing with political themes, and the architect’s revelation came only after a mean-spirited political campaign, and after House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., weighed in with his own review (“Disgusting”). That sequence of events sets a sad precedent.

Young Pulphus, for his part, has acted with restraint and dignity. His only comment: “The art speaks for itself.” So does the unseemly stampede in Ryan’s House.


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or to participate in the conversation. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.

filed under: