October 20, 2013

Barney Frank: Tea party despises government but likes what it does

And displeasure at the whole does not seem logically to fit with enthusiasm for its parts.

About 60 years ago – probably as a bar mitzvah gift – I received a big book titled “A Treasury of Jewish Humor.” One of the stories in it comes back to me now as an accurate depiction of the incoherent approach sadly taken by so many Congressional Republicans toward the role of government and its place in our society.

In general, they profess to dislike it intensely. And not content with spending so much energy on denouncing government, weeks ago they decided to take the ultimate step of demonstrating their opposition to it by shutting ours down.

In the relevant story in the book, there is another object that the protagonist of the story finds so distasteful that it induces irrational behavior: kreplach.

For those who insist that our national dialogue be conducted entirely in English, I will translate. Kreplach is a food that consists of chopped meat encased in a small envelope of dough. (As a demonstration of the universal elements that run through otherwise diverse cultures, this food is also known as ravioli or wonton.)

The story is about a mother who approaches a wise rabbi, lamenting that her young son, to use an expression that she probably did not, “freaks out” when he see kreplach. “Bring him to me,” the rabbi intones – rabbis in these stories almost always intone.

The mother obediently does so, and the rabbi takes the boy into his kitchen. Step by step, he prepares the scary food. First he rolls out the dough and asks the boy if this troubles him. “No” is the answer. Then the rabbi forms the dough into a square with a place for an insertion. “Is this a problem?” he asks. “No” comes the answer. Next the rabbi takes a bowl of chopped meat, spoons out a portion, and a third time asks if this is disturbing. “No” comes the answer for the third time.

“Ah-ha,” the rabbi says. Rabbis in this book also say “ah-ha” a lot. He puts the meat into the dough square and folds it over. Triumphantly, he holds it out to the boy, confident he has assuaged his fears.

“Ugh,” the boy shouts, “I hate it.”

Substitute Republicans for the boy and the government for kreplach and you have the government shutdown. Many Republicans – and certainly those who are calling the shots in the U.S. House today – recoil at the notion of government. But like the boy in the story, their displeasure at the whole does not seem logically to fit with their enthusiasm for its parts.

Thus, over the past weeks, we saw House Republicans alternate their denunciations of government in general with praise for its activities in particular, as they brought forward a series of bills to reinstate one at a time the government functions they shut down entirely, while blaming the president because the agencies they refused to fund do not have the money needed to function.

Logically, the concept of a whole that is smaller than the sum of its parts makes no sense. For the boy in the story and the Republicans in the House, it apparently has a logic that most of the rest of us do not appreciate.

I have had difficulty understanding why my former colleague John Boehner, who heretofore practiced a rational form of conservatism, is the enabler of this particular right-wing phobia. It is possible that he had also been given a copy of this book in his youth – though presumably not at a bar bitzvah – and understands the deep irrationality of many of his colleagues enough to dissuade him from trying to play the part of the rabbi.

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at PressHerald.com we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)