More than 1,000 faculty, administrators and staff at institutions of higher education in Maine are urging Sen. Susan Collins to vote against the nomination of Judge Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court, citing in a letter this week credible allegations of sexual misconduct and an “angry demeanor” displayed by Kavanaugh as reasons to not support him as a nominee.

“Would you hire a Maine teacher who was accused of serial and serious sexual offenses just because you did not have ‘proof beyond a reasonable doubt?'” reads the online letter. “The answer is of course no. Reasonable doubt — credible first-person testimony that an interviewee is not deserving of the job — would be enough.”

The letter, which was started by faculty from the University of New England and Bowdoin College, has over 1,000 signatures from academics within the University of Maine system, Bates College, Bowdoin College, Colby College, College of the Atlantic, University of New England and other institutions across the state.

A total of 4,729 full-time equivalent employees work in the public University of Maine system, in addition to employees at private colleges and universities.

The letter cites a statistic from the National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention stating that one in three women ages 18 and over say they have experienced sexual violence.

It goes on to say many of those who signed are survivors and have students and colleagues who are survivors of sexual violence. It says they find the allegations made by Christine Blasey Ford, who has said Kavanaugh assaulted her at a party when they were in high school in 1982, and other women credible and disturbing.


“Dr. Christine Blasey Ford’s testimony on Thursday was a powerful reminder of what we already know: women are frequently humiliated, harassed, taunted, groped, assaulted — and disbelieved,” the letter says.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY, has said the Senate plans to vote on Kavanaugh’s nomination by the end of the week, pending an FBI investigation into Ford’s allegations.

Collins, who has not said how she will vote on Kavanaugh but supported the FBI investigation, is seen as a key vote that could determine whether his nomination is approved or not.

Over the last week she has faced increasing pressure both from constituents and progressive activists urging her to vote no on his appointment and from Republican leaders who are pushing to get Kavanaugh confirmed quickly. A spokeswoman for Collins did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The letter from faculty and staff was started after a chance meeting of two faculty members, Associate Professor Lara Carlson of the University of New England and Visiting Professor Erin Johnson of Bowdoin after they met at a Sept. 28 rally outside Collins’ Portland office.

A second letter signed by an estimated 1,700 alumni, students, staff and others affiliated with Maine colleges and universities and started by two Bowdoin alums is also circulating and encouraging Collins to vote no on Kavanaugh.


“Regardless of the results of the ongoing FBI investigation, Judge Kavanaugh is not fit to serve as a Supreme Court justice,” reads the text of that letter. “His behavior in last week’s hearing demonstrates that he lacks the appropriate temperament to represent one of our greatest American institutions.”

Grace Handler, a 2017 graduate of Bowdoin, said she and fellow alum Eliza Graumlich started the letter to give universities across Maine a voice on the issue and to encourage students and others to voice their opinions to Collins.

“I think a big part of this was to bring together voices from a number of different schools of different sizes and create a unified voice,” Handler said. “That was really important to us and it was powerful to watch it happen.”

Carlson, in a news release, said, “This is a public health crisis with someone being sexually assaulted every 98 seconds in the U.S., leaving a wake of survivors. We want to make sure Senator Collins understands the magnitude of the crisis, as there are hundreds of thousands of survivors in Maine. Sexual assault crosses all party lines.”

In the letter initiated by Carlson and Johnson, the academics also said they were concerned by the demeanor of Kavanaugh during last week’s testimony on Ford’s allegations, describing his behavior as a “textbook case” of the tactics used by perpetrators of sexual assault who often deny their behavior, attack the person making the allegation and reverse the roles of victim and offender.

“We are at an historic juncture, and your vote, your words, and your actions as our representative will be a focal part of what happens this week,” reads the letter to Collins. “Will you send a message to the tens of millions of American women and men who are victims of sexual violence that their experiences will be met with indifference and even disbelief?


“Or will you make a choice for the greater good, and send the message that survivors can trust that they will be heard if they have the courage to come forward?”

Rachel Ohm — 612-2368

Twitter: @rachel_ohm

Comments are no longer available on this story