OAKLAND — Cassidy Charette, the 17-year-old Messalonskee High School student fatally injured in a hayride accident Saturday night, was a four-time honor student and regular contributor on the girls’ varsity soccer team.

Her boyfriend, 16-year-old Connor Garland, was a pitcher and first baseman for the high school baseball team and a member of the Central Maine Owls, a 15-and-under Babe Ruth baseball team that won a state championship this year.

The two had gone for a haunted hayride called “The Gauntlet” in Mechanic Falls on Saturday night when the Jeep pulling a trailer filled with passengers lost control, hit a tree and overturned, sending 23 people to the hospital. Police said Garland was “seriously injured,” and he was listed in fair condition at Boston Children’s Hospital on Sunday.

The accident has deeply affected the school community and townspeople, who have already begun to show their support for the families through social media and fundraising as well as their thoughts and prayers.

“Our hearts, the hearts of the administrators, staff and community, go out to all the folks that were involved in this,” Gary Smith, superintendent for Oakland-based Regional School Unit 18, said Sunday. “We’re with them and we grieve with them.”

Several of Charette’s soccer teammates gathered at the Messalonskee field Sunday for a brief moment of silence. Meanwhile, students and friends showed their support on social media with the phrase “Messalonskee Strong.”


The families of Charette and Garland declined to comment, as did the family of another Messalonskee student who was on the hayride and suffered less severe injuries.

Tom Bell, president of Central Maine Babe Ruth Baseball and Garland’s coach for the last seven years, said he and his son, Sam Bell, saw a report of the hayride accident on the news Sunday morning but didn’t realize right away that anyone from the Oakland area had been on the ride.

“He’s been a key part of our team for the last few years,” Bell said, referring to Garland. “It’s going to be difficult because his girlfriend was the one who died. They were down there together. We don’t know many details of what happened, but we do know he is down in Boston right now.”

Parents of the Central Maine Owls have begun fundraising efforts to help support the family while they stay in Boston, said Bell, whose son is in the junior class along with Garland. Charette was also a member of that class.

“We’re hoping for the best for Connor,” Bell said. “He’s going to have quite a recovery, and not just physically but because of the pain of losing his girlfriend.”

Sam Bell, who was playing two hockey games Sunday in between checking his phone for updates on Garland’s condition, said he had planned to visit his friend in the hospital, but right now only family are being allowed to visit.


A Facebook group called “Help the Garland Family! Messalonskee Strong!” that was providing updates on the accident Sunday said Garland was expected to undergo surgery on his jaw in the next few days and that he had broken part of his back, but that the injuries were not life-threatening. The group, which had 220 members by 6 p.m. Sunday, was also trying to raise money for the Garland family.

“I didn’t really know her on a personal level, but I know that she was really nice, smart and athletic,” Sam Bell, 15, said of Charette. “I definitely feel bad for him. I’m here for him and the families are in my prayers.”

Oakland resident Kathy Mathieu, whose son Zachary is a close friend of Garland, said Charette and Garland attended the school’s homecoming celebration together last week. She said the community is planning a fundraiser for Charette’s family, The Associated Press reported.

“Everybody is doing everything they can to help this family,” Mathieu said. “There are no words to express the sorrow for the parents.”

The accident came just one day after members of the school community attended a funeral in memory of high school senior Nora Birch, who died by suicide on Sept. 30.

Classes are not being held Monday because of the Columbus Day holiday, but the school will be open and counselors will be available from 9 a.m. to noon and from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. at the high school library. Mental health professionals will also be available to students throughout the week, according to a letter that was sent to parents by Principal Jon Moody on Sunday. The letter also mentioned that local churches will be providing support to community members.


“I feel like it’s going to be like it was a week ago,” Sam Bell said. “I feel like it will be silent in the halls.”

As girls’ soccer team members gathered briefly on the field Sunday, Eunice Spooner, 76, a former elementary school teacher in Oakland and a school board member, said she heard about the hayride accident at her church in Waterville earlier in the day. She came right to the school because she thought there might be a memorial.

“I couldn’t believe it when they said that we’d lost another Messalonskee student,” Spooner said. “How do you deal with this type of thing?”

On Monday, the Messalonskee Class of 2016 – which would have included Charette – had planned to have a “Project Graduation” fundraiser at the Red Barn Restaurant in Augusta. After checking with the family, the restaurant still plans to hold the fundraiser and a manager said Sunday night that they will possibly host a candlelight vigil as well.

“We were obviously torn given the tragedy that just happened as to whether we should do it, and the overwhelming response was that it would be the best thing for everyone. We are hoping it will be a place for everyone to come together,” said Shane Benedict, manager for the Red Barn.

Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.